ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: From "Annuity Notes" to Bank notes: A change in Bentham's Theory of Money
Author: Ghislain DELEPLACE, SIGOT Nathalie
The paper aims at studying why and how, in a very short time – from Circulating Annuities (1800) to Paper Mischief (1800-1801) and The True Alarm ([Sur les prix], 1801) –Bentham radically changed his way of formulating the problem of money and his conception of what should be done to solve it, although he maintained an approach – which may be labelled microeconomic – based on individual behaviour. In Circulating Annuities, Bentham proposed the creation by the state of a new currency – a public bond whose value would regularly increase from the interest it bears – which is presented as a way to extinguish the public debt. Although the main advantage of his plan is a financial one, he also underlines its monetary consequences: its positive effects on the growth of «national capital» and on «commercial security», as well as the ways to «obviate» the negative effects on inflation which it could bring about. In this occasion, Bentham identifies a question which, in modern economic theory, typically refers to monetary microeconomics: does money being a financial asset contribute to its acceptability as a means of payment? Nevertheless, Bentham quickly dropped his plan of «annuity notes», while remaining interested in money. In his next pamphlet, Paper Mischief, his concern was no longer for a way to increase the state revenue but for the creation of bank money and the way to regulate its quantity. In this text, his former double emphasis on the importance of a paper money issued by the state and the relevance of a paper money bearing interest abruptly disappears. One could of course attribute this move to the pressure of circumstances; at the end of his pamphlet, Bentham expressed doubts about the possibility to avoid the inflationist consequences of his plan, and one may think that he decided to turn his attention to this issue of inflation, in relation to the subject of the controversy launched by Walter Boyd in 1800: the existence or not of an excess issue of bank money. This external element certainly played a role in the abrupt change in Bentham’s monetary vision. However, another element, this time internal, should also be considered. In Circulating Annuities, Bentham also expresses doubts about the possibility to implement his plan, since it would be difficult for this new money to enter circulation on the sole basis of interest-oriented individual choice. We will show that these doubts are justified: without coercive measures, his monetary system simply could not work. Even if he did not formulate precisely a problem which monetary theory is still today at pains to explain, it is not therefore surprising that Bentham dropped a plan which he intuitively felt as inconsistent with his fundamental principles of political economy. Nevertheless, he did not renounce an approach aiming at understanding money from a microeconomic point of view. Since the return on a state money was not enough to guarantee it being demanded by the economic agents, Bentham henceforth focused on another element which he considered as crucial for the acceptability of bank money: trust. Our paper will consequently be divided in two parts. In the first one, we will show that the plan of «annuity notes» was an attempt by Bentham to base money upon interest, but that it ended in failure. In the second part, we will show that Bentham later went on looking for an approach to money based on individual behaviour, with his emphasis on the conditions required to secure the confidence of economic agents in bank money.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


