ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Three Ways of Linking Laboratory Endeavors to the Realm of Policies
Author: LEE Kyu Sang


In the present paper, I attempt to shed light on some of the representative laboratory endeavors that have recently been extended to the realm of policies. To this end, I classify them into three types, and provide a characterization of each type. Subsequently, I clarify the different notions of rationality that each type takes as crucial. The first type originated from within the economics discipline. Some of the protagonists of the first type are Vernon Smith, Charles Plott and Alvin Roth; and their intellectual progeny is called ‘economic systems design.’ Economic system designers’ explicit goal is to build robust markets or institutions where there had thitherto no markets or institutions, or where the preexisting markets or institutions did not work very well. Their favorite metaphor is ‘the economist as engineer.’ They do not attempt to directly influence decision makers’ behavior. Instead, what is to be engineered is the rule of the game. The concept of rationality some economic systems designers brought to the fore is market rationality or ecological rationality. The second type was given birth to outside of the economic discipline. Cognitive psychology or behavioral decision research was the hothouse for this type of activity. Well-known practitioners of this branch of laboratory endeavors are behavioral economists, such as Daniel Kahneman, Richard Thaler, and Colin Camerer. They have succeeded in, among other things, compiling a huge list of ‘anomalies.’ Recently, they have attracted considerable public attention by publicizing their views on policies. Libertarian paternalism (or asymmetric paternalism) is their slogan, which aptly expresses their ambition to pave a third way between laissez-faire non-interventionism and hands-on activism. Taking as the normative ideal, what logic and laws of probability prescribe, libertarian paternalists nudge ‘irrational’ decision makers in order to help them choose what they would do if they strictly followed the normative ideal. Thus libertarian paternalists do not find the metaphor, ‘economist as therapist,’ as outrageous. The final type, which originated from without the economics discipline, has a strong leader, Gerd Gigerenzer. He claims, unlike libertarian paternalists, that a heuristic is not to be considered a source of problems, but what ‘makes us smart.’ According to him, heuristics as well as environments can be designed with a view to making decision makers better off. His recent research has centered on uncovering ‘ecological rationality,’ i.e., the environmental structures that a given heuristic exploits. The aim of his research is to help decision makers, who are neither smart nor stupid intrinsically, make better decision by suggesting a heuristic that works well in a given circumstance. In addition, he proposes to make some modification to institutions in order that a certain heuristic works better in the modified institutions. Thus, one might view his laboratory endeavor as placed in between the first two types.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.