ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Economic Utopias of 1920-s: Chayanov
Author: Raskov Danila
I proceed from the assumption that in the framework of methodological pluralism the genre of utopia is to be reconsidered for better understanding of economists’ main ideas and practices. The main focus of paper is the contribution of famous agrarian economist and proponent of peasant farms Alexander Chayanov (1888-1937) who was the author of the unfinished peasant utopia “The Journey of my Brother Alexei to the Land of the Peasant Utopia” (1920)) and more academic forecasting “The Possible Future of Agriculture” (1928). These two utopias will be studed in the context of Chayanov’s scientific achievements in agrarian economics and theory of socialism. ‘Peasant utopia’ was largely noted by literary critics who found the author to have no literary talent (Shaw 1963, Clark 1985, Shushpanov 2000). Less frequently, Chayanov’s works drew the attention of economists (Kojima 2004, Coleman, Taitslin 2008). A notable exception is the detailed and thoughtful article Voprosy Chayanova (Questions of Chayanov) (Figurovskaya, Simonov 1988). A comparison of capitalism with non-capitalist economic systems (family, slave ownership, bonded serfs, feudalism and communism) shows that the distinctive aspect of “state collectivism” or socialism, according to A. V. Chayanov, consists of three categories: a state production plan, technical progress in production and non-economic means of coercion. Chaynov posed also three uncomfortable questions of socialism implementation associated with the principles in the drafting of the plan for production and consumption, with corruption of the elite, and, finally, with labor incentives. The peasant utopia of 1920 and the utopia of 1928 expose certain typological distinctions. At the centre of the peasant utopia lies a values-based approach, involving preservation of the family economy. Chayanov identifies a resolution of the core problems of socialism. State coercion is replaced with “freedom from authority”, a monopoly on the political system is replaced by democratic pluralism, the planned economy is complemented with elements of competition, and technical progress is endowed by a framework that does not disrupt the harmony of man and nature. As in ‘state collectivism’, so in the new peasant order, it is the elite, the ‘sophisticated oligarchy’ that governs. The style of the 1928 utopia comes close to being a scientific forecast. It precisely indicates the main development vector of agriculture, towards factory-based technologies. The paper is to show that utopia holds a special place in the history of economic thought, especially during 1920-s the most utopian period in soviet history.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


