ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: How to make social states comparisons with Jules Dupuit’s thought? The health-wealth hypothesis
Author: Poinsot Philippe


Many debates (theoretical and empirical) arise today on the issue of the correlation between the average life-expectancy and the average wealth among economists and demographers. Specifically these debates are based on the shape of this relation (see for instance Lynch and al. (2004)). In Jules Dupuit’s thought, this issue also arises and it is very important for two reasons. On the one hand, it refers to an original aspect of his analysis, which concerns his theory of welfare because “the average life expectancy may be considered as the true thermometer of the welfare of populations”(Dupuit, 1865: 7). He adds that the welfare of populations depends on the average wealth. In the secondary literature, only Simonin (2002) gets onto this issue; however he entirely focuses on the correlation between the average life expectancy and the level of population. So no commentator tries to explain the relation between the level of wealth and its distribution among individuals, and the average life-expectancy (or welfare) of a fixed population. On the other hand, the correlation between the average wealth and the average life-expectancy enables me to specify the way of comparing different social states from Jules Dupuit’s analysis. According to him, the goal of society is to maximise the welfare of its population by restricting the least possible natural liberty (1861: 50 and 53). So: i. state A is socially preferred to state B if natural liberty in A is higher than B, for a fixed level of welfare (which is measured by the average life-expectancy); ii. state A is socially preferred to state B if welfare (measured by the average life-expectancy) in A is higher than B, whatever the level of natural liberty in each state. But to claim that the average life-expectancy is the measuring device of welfare is not a neutral assertion: that makes Dupuit analysis focused on the relation between the average wealth and the average life-expectancy and it has many important consequences in the way he considers the issue of distribution of wealth within society. Consequently, the reconstruction of the relation between the average wealth and the average life expectancy from Dupuit’s analysis will be the first part of this paper: by referring to his theory of welfare I will define the shape of this relation. Then the consequences of this relation in social states comparisons will be tackled in the second part.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.