ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Three Levels of Abstraction in Schumpeter and Marx: History, Methodology, and Capitalism
Author: Araz Takay Bahar, Güler Aydın Derya, Özel Hüseyin
This paper is an attempt at comparing and connecting respective accounts of two important thinkers, namely, Karl Marx and Joseph Schumpeter. It is argued that these two thinkers share similar visions towards human beings, history, and capitalism, they all contend that the working of capitalism undermines its own institutional structure. In this regard, the paper seeks to establish connections between them on three grounds: Firstly, their respective accounts are characterized by historicity, that is, by the idea that human history can be understood as displaying two antinomical tendencies at once: human self expression through creative action vs. the loss of freedom due to increasing rationalization, alienation, and domination. Second, such a methodological stance also inform their understanding of capitalism, in the sense that they both devise an account of the “iron Cage”, that is, they believed that capitalism should be seen as a big leap towards more rationalization and therefore the loss of freedom, even if it creates the preconditions of the self-realization of the “species-being”, and last, but not least, they both ground their analyses of capitalism on the idea of the creative destruction in two form, as Elliott (“Marx and Schumpeter on Capitalism’s Creative Destruction: A Comparative Restatement,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 95(3), August, 1980, 45-67) emphasizes: one regarding the working of competition with its dynamic elements, and the other regarding the institutional collapse suggesting that the very success of capitalism is the basic cause of its failure. In order to show these connections, the paper focuses on three levels of abstraction in both: regarding history, the relationship between causal explanation and the “hermeneutical” (the idea of “meaning”) regarding methodology of economics and social science, their understandings of order, change and evolution; and regarding capitalism, the ideas of “creative destruction”, instability and fluctuations in the capital accumulation process. Thus, in the first section, the connection between the enlightenment thought and the hermeneutics in both will be examined, for it is argued that both were haunted by the quest to reconcile these two, seemingly contradictory, strands. The second section deals with the role of the notions of “unintended consequences” and the notions of “punctuated equilibrium” for it is the emergence and efficiency of the “social order” that they both try to explain. The third section deals with the sources of instabilities and fluctuations/crises in both, and considers the interaction between the “economic” realm, and the “rest of the society,” fort the source of the “collapse” of capitalism is due to the process of this interaction, or the “iron cage”.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


