ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The Role of “Consciousness” in Institutional Reproduction of Capitalism: An Evolutionary Game Theory Perspective
Author: Canpolat Naci, Özel Hüseyin
The paper is an attempt at constructing an evolutionary account concerning the role of the “consciousness,” not used in a narrow sense (as the term “ideology” suggests) referring to systematized world views that serve to particular sectional (or class) interests, but a broader sense that refers to the “common denomination” defining what is “meaningful” to the society as a whole, irrespective of the particular social strata that individuals belong to. In this broader, “hermeneuticist” sense, it is argued, different forms of consciousness underlie different institutional settings in a given society. These forms can also be said to shed light on the institutional reproduction and/or transformation of capitalism in general. Therefore, the present study focuses on this dimension of consciousness, by drawing upon the work of Max Weber, Karl Marx, and Karl Polanyi. The starting point of the paper is an inherent contradiction of capitalist society based on the institutional separation between the “economic” and the “political” spheres, as emphasized by these three writers. Such a separation in fact presupposes that a human being must behave as a “homo oeconomicus” within the market while she should act as a “homo reciprocan” and try to affirm her sociality only outside the market sphere. However, since a human being is not just an individual who acts on the motive of gain but she is also a social being, the assertion of human sociality takes the form of direct interventions into the working of the market itself. This contradiction between individuality and sociality will eventually create strains, if not tensions and disruptions, to the functioning of capitalism. The basic argument of the paper is that this dual existence of individuals, and the accompanying “modes of consciousness,” underlies the institutional transformation of the market system. The paper identifies two interrelated mechanisms for this process. First, this institutional separation tends to be broken by the constant interactions and the struggles between the homo economicus and the homo reciprocan, to the degree that the influence of the market over some non-market institutions, such as ethnic, religious or other types of “communities,” that has been traditionally considered as lying beyond the reach of the market. The institutional transformation that capitalism has undergone since the beginning of the twentieth century, such as liberalism, welfare state and the “neoliberal” transformation can be explained by a pendulum that swings between homo oeconomicus and homo reciprocan traits. The paper also seeks to develop an evolutionary account for this reproduction and transformation processes, informed by evolutionary game theory. It is contended that such an evolutionary game theoretic perspective can shed light on such processes, and an attempt is made at developing an evolutionary game theory model that explores the role of two different modes of consciousness, that of Homo Oeconomicus, and that of Homo Reciprocan, in hindering and or facilitating capitalist relations. Such an account is closer in spirit to Polanyi's notion of the “double movement,”This protective movement, of which the state appears as a representative, is actually part of a more general process: against the social “breakdown” caused by the extension of the market, according to Polanyi is the “self-protection” of society, or more accurately, the resistance to the commodification process carried out by different classes and organizations within the society to the extension of the market into every aspect of life, that is, to the fictitious commodities (Polanyi: 1944: 76).
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


