ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: How much competition’s guidelines have been influenced by economists?
Author: Hernández Estrada Adolfo, ROSADO CUBERO Ana Isabel


Guidelines are the framework used by judges in order to solve competition trials. They are not strictly legally binding, but they mark the line which separates the right from bad behaviour in business agreements. Guidelines have been used in United States since 1968 and have been transformed in order to accommodate the skeleton advice for the changes in a global market. The first guidelines follow the line of Joe Bain and John Bates Clark through the design of a market structure and assuming the real conduct of the companies within their markets under this kind of structure and demonstrating its natural consequence in performance. The target is to increase competition in markets and since economic theory was able to built new models they have been used as tools by lawyers, attorneys and defendants in trials. Under the lens of economists, the way to demonstrate the ugly behaviour of firms is because incumbents erect barriers to entry against their rivals; while entry barriers work incumbents will get extra-profits. The economic efficiency is erode whereas customers are the worst affected because the indicator of the existence of a barrier to entry should be a high price over the competitive price, customer must pay more than in a competitive market for the same product. Some of these economists proposals have been included in guidelines, for example, Hirschman-Herfindahl index which shows market concentration in a few companies and market power exercised by these firms in the industry; the use of installed capacity in an industry; which demonstrated the capacity of the incumbents, in all and for whichever industry, to reduce the output and raises the price. The question is whether economy theory thinks in the same way which lawyers do, because in this case the economic scientific production has to be reflected in worthwhile tools for trials. This paper tries to demonstrate how many articles could be considered as relevant in the period 1956-2000 because they have been used in guidelines, and how many of these articles were just written to confirm predecessors’ proposals. The starting date is the publication of Barriers to New Competition Joe Bain’s main book and the end date is latest guidelines publication.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.