ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: In Favor of Rigor and Relevance. A Reply to Mark Blaug
Author: KURZ Heinz D., Salvadori Neri


Mark Blaug has written another paper in which he attacks “Sraffian economics”. He characterises his piece as “a new version of an earlier effort [that] extends and hopefully deepens the argument” (Blaug 2009, 219 n. 2). A careful scrutiny of the paper shows that Blaug reiterates once again his previous criticisms, adds a few new ones, but does not enter into a serious discussion of the replies to his earlier efforts. Answering him in detail would necessitate repeating again our counter-arguments. We spare the readers this and ask them to consult our earlier replies to Blaug. Instead, we provide an overall assessment of Blaug’s various attacks on “Sraffians” and draw readers’ attention to a significant change in direction in his recent one. In addition we refute a number of contentions and remarks by Blaug. Our comment is composed as follows. We begin with a characterization of Blaug’s respective efforts (section 1). Next we refute his contention that Sraffa’s analysis is a species of Walrasian general equilibrium theory (section 2). We then show that he is wrong in contending that “Sraffians” have not dealt with a number of problems tackled by the classical authors (section 3). Finally we scrutinise and reject his contention that “Sraffian economics” is not fruitful economics (section 4). We conclude with a plea for rigor and relevance (section 5).

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.