ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Mandeville’s market seen through the 18’th century coffee-house culture
Author: Nakano Satoko
This paper partly relates to the conference theme, ‘The Practices of Economists in the Past and Today’, in that it considers the role of coffee-house culture of the 18th century in London in shaping Mandeville’s economic insight into the market interactions. The satirical and poetic style of Mandeville’s writings stems from the journalism and atheism that pervade the coffee houses in London, where not only writers and philosophers but also businessmen and traders stayed and communicated each other. Although the role of public space such as coffee houses for the development of Enlightenment has been noted by various historians and the place of Mandeville in the Enlightenment thought has been highly appraised, the role and implication of coffee-house culture in Mandeville’s economic analysis has not necessarily been made clear. Mandeville’s economic analysis has two seemingly contradicting aspects: on one hand, economic liberalism, on the other hand, interventionism. These inconsistent interpretations have been solved to some extent by using the conception of evolution of legal institutions in society, as is seen in Hayek’s spontaneous orders. However, this interpretation is biased toward the natural law tradition seen in Hume and Smith. Mandeville’s thought can be, religiously and philosophically, distinguished from this Scottish tradition. Mandeville has a unique atomistic vision, Epicurean atomism, —a construction of order through cognitive interactions in the skeptical tradition followed since P. Gassendi and P. Bayle and in its relation to British Empiricism advocated by J. Locke, G. Berkeley, and D. Hume, which is discussed in my independent paper, “Mandeville's Skepticism Seen in His Probabilistic View for the Market” presented in 2007 HES annual conference”. This cognitive discussion can be comprehensible as an economic insight into market interactions developed in coffee-houses, where traders are prompted to their economic activities under uncertainty, receiving and casting various information that include deceiving ones. These processes finances trading, expands the market and ultimately enables the development of the division of labor in the society as an unintended result. Parts of explanations of the process share some behavioral descriptions with those of the behavioral economics and neural economics of the present day. This mechanism can be contrasted with the establishment of rules of justice in a moral space of a civil society. Smith based economics on this moral space and did not include Mandeville’s cognitive processes in his economic system. Mandeville’s contradictory characteristic involving both the liberalistic and intervening aspects becomes comprehensible by elucidating Mandeville’s psychological philosophy as a vivid descriptive device for the course of things in coffee-house culture.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


