ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: What Can We Learn From Adam Smith?
Author: STURN Richard
Widely popularized views of Adam Smith as a champion of unfettered self-interest and free marketeering are under fire these days. In much of the more recent literature, emphasis is put on aspects of his oeuvre condradicting such orthodox reading. In this paper, I wish to sketch some perspectives which may shed critical light on some of the “new” attempts to “appropriate” Smith. My goal is a constructive one: I wish to show that the usefulness of Smith’s oeuvre for modern economics as a discipline aiming at “light and fruit” (Pigou 1938, 3) is enhanced by two things which are sometimes lacking: first, by paying attention to the architecture of his oeuvre, and, second, by taking seriously Smith’s research strategy as an economist. As a by-product, I will suggest that new claims to exclusive appropriation of Smith (like corresponding old claims by free marketeers and believers in other orthodoxies) compromise the potential use of Smith’s thought with its surprising scope as a non-depletable public good. The contestedness of interpretation is used as a starting point for understanding Smith as a multi-level thinker and his emphasis on the dynamism of tensions. Smith is shown to be an interesting author for modern readers in general and modern economists as he deals with some crucial issues and remaining challenges, such as: − the autonomous logic of the market vs. its institutional embedment; − the status of parsimonious models vs. the conditions of critique invoking wider horizons, more complex interdependences, or different levels of argument; − how to preserve a unified theoretical core while allowing for reasonable disagreement; and − how to reconcile persuasively straightforward arguments with qualified conclusions.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


