ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Quesnay and the mercantilists on productive labour
Author: PERROTTA Cosimo
Quesnay’s thought on productive labour is one of the most notorious subjects in the history of economics. However it has never been compared with the previous thought on the same issue. In fact the debate on productive labour (the labour which adds to national wealth) does not begin with Quesnay, as most historians still believe. It starts at least with Petty and goes on for nearly a century before arriving at the founder of physiocracy. Here we argue that such a comparison can cast new light on some neglected aspects of Quesnay’s thought. In particular it puts in evidence the rigid and static nature of Quesnay’s conception, much more than a comparison between the latter and Smith. The mercantilists put a distinction between more or less productive works. Besides they conceived the productive nature of works in terms of use values (not of quantity, as Quesnay does). Finally they thought that many jobs can be unproductive not in an absolute sense bat if the workers of that sector are too many. Then they had a flexible and empiric idea of productive labour. Quesnay instead makes the distinction between productive and unproductive labour a sort of metaphysical entity, not modifiable (see also how he treats the subject while writing of the laws of nature). In the end, since the productivity of agricultural labour is given only by nature, labour per se, either in agriculture or in manufacturing, becomes a mere exchange of present goods for future goods, like the commercial jobs. Thus labour becomes only a secondary factor in the process of wealth production. Quesnay’s approach is confirmed by his analysis of foreign trade. To him only export of agricultural products is productive, because it supports agricultural production. On the contrary the other import-export activities, being mere exchanges, damage the national economy because subtract labourers and capitals from the true production of wealth. Such a comparison makes the fact more meaningful that Quesnay connects explicitly his ideas on productive labour and on the primacy of agriculture with the pre-modern culture; which was hostile to both manufacturing and economic development as such. He also refers to the anti-mercantilist French tradition; especially to Sully and his programme of developing France only through agriculture.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


