ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Fourier versus Owen on the issue of justice
Author: Ragip EGE, RIVOT Sylvie
Fourier and Owen are considered as theoreticians belonging to the current of the so called utopian socialism. Indeed they both imagine and try to create a society shaped according to the model of an association on a human scale: “phalanstere” for Fourier and “parallelogram” for Owen. In nineteenth century many social reformists are convinced that this model offers the unique condition to prevent the exploitation of the man by the man. In other words “phalanstere” and “parallelogram” are conceived by our authors as the promise of a radically new world, the promise of a society where the justice is finally realised. But a closer examine of the two doctrines shows that the concept of justice Fourier’s approach of the society involves is noticeably different form the Owen’s one. In this communication we will analyse this difference and attempt to appreciate its theoretical implications. Our aim is to exhibit the originality and the profoundness of Fourier’s concept of justice regarding to the one of Owen. But to be fair to the work of Owen, we must not forget that Fourier’s utopia remained more or less on a purely abstract and theoretical level, as he waited for years each Tuesday for a patron who would help him to realise his plans. By contrast, Owen’s work cannot be restricted to his writings, as he was fully involved in the implementation of new methods of management in his New Lanark factory, and even created himself the community of New Harmony. In this way, Owen’s views are more pragmatic than Fourier’s, since the former tried to improve the livelihood of labour at his time, and the conditions of children’s life, in a dramatic economic context. Indeed, Owen’s views have been considered more valuable at his time and after, precisely because of their realism. At first we stress on the relation between the problematic of justice and the question of labour and fair distribution of the product. Owen militates in favour of the abolition of the private property; people in his communities are assumed to be perfectly equal. For him, the character of the individual can be changed as wished through the modification of the circumstances in which he evolves: mankind is totally malleable. The worker would be induced to work for the good thanks to both the stifling of his bad instincts and the stimulation of his moral and generous tendencies. Owen’s reformations never take into account actual desires, inclinations, passions, ideals of the individuals whose conditions of existence it would wish to improve. On the other hand, Fourier shows himself as a true defender of the private property, and he advocates for a community as unequal as possible, in which people are remunerated in accordance to their contribution in terms of capital, labour, and talent. Here, the individual would be induced to work as he would be spontaneously attracted to labour: it won’t be needed to shape a better individual, but to let him to open out his passions, both bad and good. In particular, a fair distribution would be insured thanks to accomplishment of both the greedy and the generous instincts. In the world of Fourier justice is called to realise the conditions of the coexistence of the diversity and the multiplicity of passions and desires and not of the strict equality and uniformity between individuals. Secondly, the difference between respective approaches of the two theoreticians of the question of the reformation reveals the difference between their conception of social knowledge or social science. Closely examined, the concept of justice Owen’s doctrine involves is quite expeditious and “scientistic” (to use a French neologism). His “science of the circumstances” is supposed to provide all the necessary means, instruments and techniques to solve the social question and to lead individuals to the happiness. Such knowledge entails evidently qualified people supposed to have assimilated it and in that capacity they are authorised to manage the community, to organise and to shape social reality. Owen’s social conception is profoundly paternalistic. In his world, individual happiness will be realised “for him” but not “by him”. By contrast, Fourier does not harbour any design to shape the real; he doesn’t feed any will to re-educate mankind. On the contrary, he pretends to have discovered the true principle of functioning of the world: the principle of passions attraction (quite as the Newtonian principle of physical attraction). But such principle doesn’t involve a “social science” in the sense that its assimilation could automatically bring the happiness to the community. The principle of functioning of the world teaches the theoretician the necessity to delete the constraints which prevent the realisation of the desire. In the world of Fourier happiness is seen as the problem of the individual and not of the social scientist. Such world is much more confident in mankind because “the true happiness consists only in satisfying ones passions” (CW 1, 83). Thus one can say that Owen harbours a teleological view of society which, in turn, involves a paternalistic conception of justice. By contrast, Fourier’s conception of the society is not teleological and, in this sense, his conception of justice does not involve paternalism.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


