ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Retracing “works-in-progress” of economists and their practises through their archives
Author: CAMPAGNOLO Gilles
In line with the theme “practises of economists”, one major issue is methodological: how do we (historians of economic thought and philosophers) retrace how the economists whom we study indeed worked. How to know their “work-in-progress”? What does it teach to retrace it? Cases are various according to whether we deal with past/present authors and whether archives are available, or not. This presentation deals with past economists whose archives are available. It uses the example of resources long left in oblivion because of their distant location (here: Japan). Given material sources indeed exist, many facets in digging up archives and exploring legacies that bear testimony of “work-in-progress” deserve attention – first, methodological aspects: conditions of access to archives and their contents (how to sort them out, what to select for editing/publishing, what to comment on for research articles/books). That actually concerns our practise, but it delivers information about the practises of those authors too: what they read, and how, what they intended to publish/leave unpublished, revise, supplement etc. Second aspect dealt with is “social epistemology”: claims to inheritance (both legal and intellectual) and the way discoveries of previously unpublished / unknwon material impact them. That present concern is related to past practises because authors built schools of thought, groups and/or influential currents. How economists saw their role reflect in the way they practised it. Material, social and theoretical issues are entangled. The reward for that inquiry is the ability to find new material/themes, retrace “works-in-progress” that may at least partly change views today accepted about authors and re-orientate research. The researcher of today bears responsibility when retracing those past practises because it entails some judgment on those at present. In times of crisis, this is indeed a relevant task. This presentation details three cases: Carl Menger, Karl Bücher, Werner Sombart – all of whose archives are located in Japan. Drawing first an inventory of the collections (thus also hinting at the way archives “imported” in Japan influenced the local academia), the presentation insists on what we learn about the way the three German-speaking authors worked. Archives help ‘profiling’ them with even more likeness (bibliographically, indeed also biographically). The standpoint adopted here is historical and biographical, but we believe it, to some extent, also philosophical, because conceptual schemes explaining past practises re-emerge into modern philosophical issues, issues of philosophy in and of economics.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


