ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: A note on Ragnar Frisch and the concept of «equilibrium»
Author: Trabucchi Paolo
A brief paper from the middle of the 1930s by the Norwegian economist Ragnar Frisch («On the Notion of Equilibrium and Disequilibrium» published in 1936 on the Review of Economic Studies) is commonly regarded as one of the seminal works in the birth of modern «dynamic» economic theory. After the enthusiastic references by such authorities as Samuelson and Schumpeter, Frisch’s paper has indeed become the locus classicus for a comprehensive discussion of the role that in a «dynamic» theory concepts such as «equilibrium», «disequilibrium», «statics», «stationary state», «stability», etc. should have. Though views still differ regarding the precise content of modern «dynamic» economic theory, it is generally maintained that it is to a certain extent opposed to the theory that prevailed in the Nineteenth century, as this is supposed to have been confined to the study of stationary conditions. It should come then very much as a surprise that Frisch wrote his paper in order to answer certain criticisms that had been moved in the 1930s against Wicksell – i.e. against one of the authors often pointed at as an example of the «stationary» approach – and his notion of a «normal» rate of interest. Indeed, Frisch’s work is particularly clear-cut in showing how the concept of a «normal» equilibrium (generally adopted by the first marginalist authors) was designed as a tool for the study of changing, and not stationary, economies. In this respect Frisch’s hint to the effect that the concept of a «normal» equilibrium is specific to economic theory is certainly suggestive. Moreover, Frisch shows how the development of a «dynamic» economic theory similar to what is meant under this term in theoretical mechanics (a goal that has often been pronounced impracticable but that Frisch strongly advocated) had to be thought independently of the very notion of equilibrium. This seems to undermine the widespread belief that the notions of «temporary», or «intertemporal», equilibrium have in some way contributed to the construction of a truly «dynamic» economic theory. Weintraub has recently drawn the attention on the one-sidedness of Samuelson’s use of Frisch’s contribution. It seems however that, in neglecting Frisch’s discussion of the notion of a «normal» equilibrium, he has not gone to the bottom of the matter. A closer look at Frisch’s classical paper appears then still worthwhile.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


