ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Thomas Hepburn and Eighteenth-Century Orcadian Economy: the Moderate Economic Thought of Edinburgh Reconsidered
Author: Furuya Hiroyuki
This paper aims to cast light on some aspects of political economy in the Scottish Enlightenment and of the Moderate economic thought of Edinburgh in the Church of Scotland in the eighteenth century. The main source is a tract titled A Letter to a Gentleman from his Friend in Orkney, containing the True Causes of the Poverty of that Country (1760), written by a little-known Orkney Presbyterian minister Thomas Hepburn (1727?-1777). Written in 1757, Hepburn’s Letter lively described from his own firsthand experience why the Orkneys were left in poverty, in contrast with mainland Scotland becoming increasingly wealthy under the Union of 1707. Throughout his Letter, Hepburn held local Orkney lairds responsible for most of the causes of poverty. Especially, Hepburn criticised the widespread oppression by the Orkney lairds, and their faction in a lawsuit called the Pundlar Process ongoing in Edinburgh at that time, in which the lairds as plaintiffs, alleged that the weights by which the feu-duties were payable to the Earl of Morton, had been augmented no less than three-fifths above the original standard in the Earldom estates. In due course, Hepburn defended Morton, whose business-like resolve to introduce modern and unified standards suitable for the new, expanding market economy under the Union, provoked a widespread resistance among the local lairds. This particular background made Hepburn appreciate the spread of the market economy under the Union as a powerful and useful weapon of tackling the real problems of poverty and the old system of protections, sharing some characteristics of the European Enlightenment as a criticism of the status quo and a practical policy proposal. Though little known abroad, it could be hardly surprising that, within Scotland under the Union until now in the twenty-first century, Hepburn’s Letter has been republished from time to time. Richard Sher has argued that the economic thought of the Moderate literati who were based in and around Edinburgh, where ‘improvement’ was most advanced, could be characterised by their primary concern for the moral and social ramifications of economic development. Eighteenth-century Scotland however, ‘improved’ unevenly from region to region, and consequently, the economic thought of the Moderates of Edinburgh had a wider, nationwide scope and more various concerns. These included the root cause of poverty in the remote islands like the Orkneys, where the benefits of ‘improvement’ and expanding commerce had not yet been felt.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


