ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: INDIVIDUAL CHOICE AND HAPPINESS: THE MISFORTUNE OF DESIRE OF INFINITE WEALTH IN THINGS OF G.PEREC
Author: PIGNOL Claire


We use a novel of G.Perec, entitled 'Things: A Story of the Sixties', to question the relation between individual choice in consumption and happiness. The object of the paper is to stress a particular case of separation between desire, choice and happiness, due to the desire of an infinite wealth, which can never be satisfied and causes both apathy and misfortune of the characters. This is the paradoxical situation Perec describes in his novel, which is the narration of the frustration created by the desire of an infinite wealth. How can this narration be understood from an economic viewpoint? Even if the standard agent of economic theory desires an unlimited wealth, it does not prevent him from enjoying his lot, whereas Perec’s characters feel miserable when they realize they would prefer something more than they have. They want to reach a satiation consumption in which happiness would result from the feeling that nothing misses to it. The difficulty is that this satiation consumption, if it exists, moves off as their wealth increases, just as the horizon. This unlimited desire is the cause of a feeling of misfortune and, furthermore, prevents them from doing anything to improve their welfare. They are paradoxically led to apathy and to a collapse of desires which leaves them as unhappy and frustrated as they were with their unsatisfied desires. That’s why these feelings seem to be an enigma from standard economic theory’s point of view. We’ll examine a few ways by which modern theory offers to solve this enigma. We’ll first look at the debates initiated by Galbraith’ book, The affluent society, according to which the apparent sovereignty of consumers hides the creation and control of consumers’ desires by firms, through the influence of advertising. Galbraith’s argument is not sufficient to draw the welfare implications from changing preferences, since the traditional objections against interpersonal utility functions forbid any attempt to assess whether the individual becomes better or worse off as his tastes change. We’ll then turn to the literature on meta-rankings, which establish a preference order on the different preference orders, allowing comparisons and implications on welfare. The discussion will focus on the possibility to express through the concept of meta-ranking the increasing unhappiness felt by Perec’s characters in proportion as their wealth increases.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.