ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Veiling The Controversies with Dubious Moral Attitudes? Keynes and the Ethics of International Relations
Author: Carabelli Anna, Cedrini Mario Aldo
Despite Keynes's reiterated insistence, both in the context of the two World Wars and in the interwar period, on the moral dimension of international economic relations, the literature has so far given scarce attention to the issue. With few exceptions, economists and historians tend rather to put the blame for some outstanding failures of Keynes's economic diplomacy on the presumed instrumental use Keynes made of moral arguments. To use the very words the editors of the American review New Republic wrote to oppose Keynes's view of the American debt settlement at the end of World War I, Keynes is often said to be "veiling the controversy" with "dubious moral attitudes", i.e. to employ moral arguments to counterbalance the weakness of Britain's case. The fact itself that moral arguments enter some key documents of Keynes's diplomacy, as in the case of the memorandum "Overseas Financial Policy in Stage III", where his plans for the transition to the new order of Bretton Woods are named “Justice”, is more often than not seen as the weak element of a strategy destined to fail in any event or an ill-conceived tactic to obtain the desired result. Yet, the moral dimension of Keynes's arguments for coordinated international adjustment or global architectural reform is never investigated in depth. What is more, by so doing, economists and historians are generally bound to dismiss the relevance of the dilemmatic nature of decision-making in the international system conceived of by Keynes as a complex system characterized by organic interdependence and heterogeneity of policies. In the paper, we provide a comprehensive account of the ethical arguments used by Keynes in his longlife attempt to design a fair international order, and revisit, with special concern for the moral and methodological issues involved, some of the crucial episodes of his economic diplomacy and suggestions for global reform. We thus aim to demonstrate that far from being the weak element in the search for a sounder political economy between all nations, the moral dimension of Keynes's diplomacy helps clarify his ethics of international relations. The theoretical bases for this ethics are found in that same anti-utilitarian philosophy which underlies his approach to economics – whose task consists in trying to eradicate the "economic problem" – as an instrument, and the precondition to enjoy what he defined as a "moral life", safeguarding variety while widening, as he wrote in the "General Theory", "the field for the exercise of personal choice".
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


