ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The ambiguous relation between rationality and explanation
Author: LAGUEUX Maurice


If rationality is such an important concept in economics it is clearly because it plays a fundamental role in explanation. However, this hardly disputable fact is seriously hidden by the very way rationality is understood by contemporary economists. Indeed, if rationality is defined by maximization or consistency, it is difficult to see how economic behaviour could be explained with the help of such an abstract conception of rationality. As was largely illustrated by behavioural economics, people are poor maximisers and can hardly avoid frequently being inconsistent. In this context, pretending that such a counterintuitive view of rationality can explain economic behaviour is simply preposterous, in such a way that many economists of our time, conceiving of themselves as model builders, flatly deny that it is their role to provide explanations. If some are forced to provide explanations, they often tend to look for explanations that are not based on what they call “rationality”, but rather on biological or neurological forces. For economists of the past, at least for classical economists, explaining specifically economic phenomena was the main contribution of economists. Even though they do not use the word “rationality”, their explanations were based on what can be described as a rationality postulate, which means that they postulate, quite realistically, that people are sensible enough to modify their behaviour, after some time, when it becomes clearly harmful to themselves and to maintain this behaviour when it turns out to be clearly profitable. In this fashion, they were able to analyse a properly economic mechanism. With the so-called marginalist revolution, economists became designers of models that might work like natural sciences models. Therefore, they relinquished the realistic view of rationality and replaced it by maximisation. This move, which transformed rationality into a fantastic capacity, has contributed to dissolving the link between rationality and explanations, but it has not totally destroyed it since maximisation, while being an unilateral amplification of rationality, may nonetheless stand for rationality in an argument. It is only when the meaning of the word “rationality” was extended still further to designate consistency that the link between rationality and explanation was definitively broken, since consistency as defined by contemporary economists contradicts the adaptive behaviour, which characterises genuine rationality and explains economic behaviour. The paper will more systematically explore this radical difference between the respective (theoretical) practices of economists of the past and of today.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.