ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The Price Level in the Keynes-Hayek-Sraffa Exchange of the Early 1930s
Author: ANDREWS David


The debate over monetary theory and policy among J.M. Keynes, Friedrich Hayek and Piero Sraffa in the early 1930s stands out as a remarkable event in the history of economic thought. Leading representatives of three significantly different approaches to economic theory engaged head to head on central theoretical issues in major economics journals. Keynes’s Treatise on Money was published in 1930. Hayek wrote a highly critical two part review of Keynes’s book that was published in 1931 and 1932. Hayek’s Prices and Production was first published in 1931. Keynes’s response to Hayek’s review, which morphed into a review of Hayek’s book, was published in 1931. Hayek then wrote a response to Keynes’s rebuttal. Keynes invited Sraffa to intervene with a review of Hayek’s book and that review was published in 1932. This brought a response from Hayek which was followed by a further comment by Sraffa. While the episode has received considerable attention in the literature, one important aspect has been overlooked, namely, the fact that on one issue, the use of the indexes of price levels, Sraffa and Hayek were united in opposition to Keynes. While price indexes played important roles in Keynes’s theory, both Hayek and Sraffa argued that they should play no role in monetary theory. This paper is concerned to examine this aspect of the exchange. This paper begins with Keynes’s early essay on price indexes and his theoretical position in the Treatise on Money. Then it examines the nature of Hayek’s explicit objection. Next the paper turns to Sraffa. He did not develop his own objection to the general price level in detail, and he appears to commend Hayek’s position. Nevertheless, I argue that this appearance is misleading. The paper next examines Keynes’s response to these objections, and concludes that while Keynes first defended his original position from both Hayek and Sraffa, he later came, in the General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, to hold the position that Sraffa had taken.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.