ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Where to draw the line between laissez-faire and planning? Keynes and Friedman on public and semi-public institutions
Author: RIVOT Sylvie


Keynes and Friedman are said to be at odds on the economic policy to be implemented: interventionism for the former, laissez-faire for the latter. However, a more careful study of these authors shows that they share an common opposition to the fine tuning of the economy, and that both of them would, in a way, favour rules over discretion. The paper aims to take up this debate, focusing on the institutional framework they respectively advocate for. As these authors obviously do not share the same optimism on the self-adjusting capacity of the economy, it seems worthwhile to analyze the role attributed to public institutions, such as the monetary authority or the government, but also the place allowed to semi-public bodies, such as the port of London for Keynes or the US postal service for Friedman. Our route of investigation will be triple. First, we briefly recall Keynes’ and Friedman’s respective views on the efficiency of a laissez-faire economy and we shed light on the role played by semi-public bodies and the behaviour of the ‘big company’. Here, it is their respective confidence in the self-adjusting capacity of the economy and their respective comprehension of the collective rationality that is at stake. In the second part of the paper, their respective pleas on the task assigned to the state, and in particular to the fiscal policy and the monetary authority are analysed. Here, it is shown that Keynes’ and Friedman’s positions are a mix of points of agreement, advocacies hardly reconcilable and also definitive splits between them. Basically, what they have in common is the necessity to provide a stable framework, in which private agents are able to coordinate themselves. However, what characterises the latter Friedman is a basic distrust towards the state – except in its duty restricted to the preservation of a stable institutional framework, whereas for Keynes efficiency and stability would not be guaranteed without a determined involvement of the state. Here, it is their respective understanding of the coordination among markets that is at stake. Finally, how to explain such contrasting views on the rationality of the existing institutions and on the necessity for new public bodies to be implemented? There is first their respective interpretation of the Great Depression. Beyond, our hypothesis is that one of the clues to their respective understanding of the role played by public and semi-public institutions is to be found in their respective conception of uncertainty, and thus of money. Here, we follow North (1991, 97) who states that “institutions have been devised by human beings to create order and reduce uncertainty in exchange”. In Friedman’s theoretical framework, it is risk rather than uncertainty that prevails. Hence, a stable institutional framework, in which the role attributed to the state is restricted to the minimum, is enough to keep the economic machine well-oiled. The key-task of the state is to ensure a competitive framework so that individuals can easily coordinate themselves. For Keynes, quite the contrary is true. The stable economic framework required refers actually to institutions to be implemented; it does in no way emerge spontaneously. Indeed, because of true uncertainty faced by the individuals, the state is led to take a growing role in the economy, so as to coordinate individuals, to drive expectations and behaviours.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.