ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Classical economic theories and the crash of 2008
Author: Mireles Flores Luis


In a recent article, Geoffrey Hodgson (2009) conjectures whether the recent economic crisis of 2008 would set off a reform of economics. Among his many points, he suggests that current economic theorists might have become somewhat detached from economic reality by an excess of abstraction and formalisation in their academic endeavours. To counteract this tendency, Hodgson makes several suggestions, one of which urges for a more serious study of the history of economic thought by economists. The present essay is meant to illustrate and qualify such a suggestion with a case study. At the beginning of the 19th century, just after the Napoleonic wars, a number of economic crises harmed England, France, and to a certain extent all Europe. Several economists at the time started developing and discussing theories meant to explain the workings of the markets and the causes behind economic crises. Two different theoretical positions then contended with each other as the “correct” explanation. This has become to be known as the general glut controversy. On the one hand, the classical theory of markets, usually associated to the works of J.-B. Say, though Adam Smith, James Mill, David Ricardo, and J. S. Mill also contributed to its shape. On the other hand, the theory of general overproduction, held (with some differences) by Thomas Malthus and Simonde de Sismondi, among others. The so-called general glut controversy has been studied by many historians of economic thought. Nevertheless the present essay intends to stress a particular aspect about this controversy that deserves further exploration: the strong practical concerns that rested behind the theories involved. Both sides expressly wanted to clarify the causes of economic crises so as to be able to come up with the appropriate policy recommendations to deal with crises in the real world. This attitude obviously contrasts with Hodgson’s diagnosis about the current state of the discipline. Understanding the sense in which classical economists (and their theories) were connected to real economic phenomena could contribute to a better understanding of the sense in which current theorists might be to some extent detached from it. Furthermore, the analysis also shows that the theories involved were in fact very abstract and in a certain way formal as well. This sheds light on how economic theories could be abstract (and formal) and yet stay connected to reality in relevant respects. For this, the article traces most of the idealizing assumptions that were presupposed by both sides of the controversy. This serves to add some qualifications to Hodgson’s suggestions about what exactly is there to be learned from the history of economic thought.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.