ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: A missed “Financial Revolution” from England? Silhouette, Forbonnais and French Finances during the Seven Years’ War (1759)
Author: ORAIN Arnaud
It is well known that during the very short ministry (March-November 1759) of the contrôleur général Etienne de Silhouette (1709-1767), François Véron de Forbonnais (1722-1800) was his first adviser. Both men lost the confidence of the King and his mistress, Madame de Pompadour, and were abandoned after the great opposition raised in reaction to the new taxation system proposed in October/November 1759, the so-called subvention générale. This subvention planned the creation of a wide range of new taxes, especially upon luxury goods by the reinforcement of the indirect taxation system. Prepared by Forbonnais, this plan reflected some of his ideas on taxation presented in the Considérations sur les finances d’Espagne (1753a) and the Recherches et considérations sur les finances de la France (1758). In these books, Forbonnais puts forward the virtue of the British taxation system and proposed indirect taxes with progressive rates inversely proportional to the utility of the goods. These are to be accompanied by a real tax on land based on an unbiased land registry, which would take into account the quality of land and agricultural products. This last idea was not developed by Silhouette and Forbonnais, certainly due to a lack of time, but the new taxes upon luxury goods and the exemption for necessary goods (butter, eggs and cheese) seems to be an application of the ideas of Forbonnais on progressiveness. But here, we have to stop for a moment: is the influence coming from just one source? The answer is clearly much more difficult than the ideas of the previous commentators on the subject would have us believe. We know indeed that Silhouette wrote in the 1740’s some Observations sur les finances, le commerce et la marine de l’Angleterre en octobre 1747 where he praises a system of indirect taxation and the virtue of real taxes with regards to personal ones before the French economist had done so. In fact, it seems that this is a common point of view which has grown up between the two men, much more than a Contrôleur général under the influence of a thinker. So, does the system of the subvention générale reflect the ideas of Forbonnais? Of Silhouette? Of both? Why was it a failure? What was the role played by the General Farm in this plan? Is there common points with the ministry Turgot, especially concerning the suppression of obstacles to free trade? There are very many questions here which this article will try to answer, after a detailed presentation of the ideas and achievements of our two men.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


