ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The first economic policy proposal: William Petty and the origination of the practice of the economist.
Author: Goodacre Hugh


William Petty’s scheme to transfer the bulk of the population of Ireland into England did not lack precedents as a policy proposal with aims that could broadly be described as economic; such proposals had been put forward since ancient times, and the projectors and arbitristas of the sixteenth century onwards had been responsible for a whole genre of literature of such a character. Petty’s proposal does, however, have a unique status in the history of the economic policy proposal in the sense in which that term is now understood, both from a theoretical point of view, and also, arguably, from the point of view of the practical measures which he adopted to promote it. His scheme had two principal aims. First, it would increase the advantages of compactness of population in England, such compactness being, in his view, the key to the advantages enjoyed by Holland, which was, in his time, not only Europe’s most densely-populated country, but also its most economically-advanced. The second main aim of the scheme was to “cut up the roots of those evils” which “have made Ireland, for the most part, a diminution and a burthen, not an advantage, to England”. Petty’s final work, his Treatise of Ireland, aims precisely to quantify the supposed balance of this ‘burthen’ and ‘advantage’, and to suggest that it could be reversed by the implementation of his scheme through the advantages of spatial compactness that it would bring; in today’s terms, his aim is to carry out a cost-benefit analysis. The proposal is presented in a format which is so familiar today – as an economic policy proposal – that it is easy to forget that this was, at the time, his own singular innovation. For, unlike the ‘projectors’ who preceded him, he not only backed his recommendations with a combination of statistical and cost-benefit analysis, but also an explicit theoretical framework. In that sense, the entire tradition of ‘applied economics’, as it is now understood, follows in the footsteps of Petty’s pioneering proposal. His promotion of his scheme through the exploitation of highly-placed personal contacts has traditionally been regarded as ill-judged and even somewhat ridiculous. However, recent historical research indicates that his supposed shortcomings in this regard have in the past been exaggerated, and that here too his activities constitute a not-insignificant chapter in the pioneering of the role of the economist.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.