ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Interactions Between Political Economy and Agronomy: Question of Returns on Land
Author: KAYA Alp Yücel


There is a very tide relationship between political economy and agronomy, especially in the 18th and 19th centuries. Some important concepts in political economy were influenced by agronomy. The question on returns on land is one of these concepts. In the 19th century, most classical political economists (i.e. Malthus, Ricardo, Say, Rossi, etc.) accepted the argument of diminishing returns on land as the universal law of agricultural production, according to which the produce of land increases in a diminishing ratio to the increase in the labor employed. As Argemi [2002] notes: “From J. Anderson and Turgot, the idea of diminishing returns passed on to Ricardo, who based the origin of rent on it... Later, von Thünen included the distance variable beside the quality variable. As a final step, the principle of decreasing returns was later generalized to all the factors of production, not only land. As such, it is the cornerstone of marginal analysis”. This idea, however, needs a reassessment by acknowledging that the idea of increasing returns on land was also prominent in most of the 18th-19th century agronomic literature (i.e. Jethro Tull, James Anderson, Albrecht Thaer, Elie-Victor-Benjamin Crud, Mathieu de Dombasle, etc.) which was continuously in search of rational techniques of cultivation in order to increase agricultural productivity and profitability: the introduction of new instruments which spare manual labor, such as winnowing and threshing machines; technical and technological improvements in the land pulling instruments which not only increase the productivity but also decrease costs of productions, such as the introduction new ploughing systems. John Stuart Mill argued alike that the diminishing returns exist only under the given and constant technological framework and one can achieve the increasing returns under the technological change. This challenge to the law of diminishing returns found also an echo in the works of some critical political economists (i.e. Engels, Marx, Kautsky, Lenin) who focused also “on the capacity of humanity through its interaction with nature to improve or undermine the fertility of the soil” (Foster 2007). The main reference of Engels and Marx for improvement of the productivity of the soil was an agronomist, Justus von Liebig. But, except for Von Liebig, neither critical political economists of the 19th century nor Mill do not mention names of other main agronomists of the 19th century, such as Albrecht Thaer, Elie-Victor-Benjamin Crud and Mathieu de Dombasle who had a conception of increasing returns in their entire work. In this paper, I will therefore question these complex interactions between political economy and agronomy on the basis of question of returns on land.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.