ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: On the Origin and Purpose of the Economic Theory of Clubs
Author: Pickhardt Michael
In this paper I address three research issues. First, I trace the origin of James M. Buchanan’s (1965) Economic Theory of Clubs directly back to the writings of Knut Wicksell (1896) and Emil Sax (1878). In particular, I show that Wicksell`s formalization of Sax’s original idea can be regarded as the analytical basis of modern club theory (see also Pickhardt 2005, 2006, 2007). Next, I turn the analysis to the prime purpose of Buchanan’s (1965) Club Theory, that is, the attempt to close the ‘awesome Samuelson [1954] gap’ between purely private and purely public goods with club goods. I argue that the habit of using the number of club members to summarize the interdependence between club members conceals important matters, especially with respect to the dichotomy of public versus private goods. I show that some minor changes to Buchanan’s original modeling procedure are sufficient for making this interdependence more transparent. Yet, as a consequence, it turns out that any consumption act within the club is either rival or nonrival. In other words, I demonstrate that the continuum of goods ranging from purely private over club goods to purely public goods, as proposed by Buchanan (1965) does not exist. To this extent, it is neither necessary to extend nor to abandon the distinction between private and public goods developed by Paul A. Samuelson (1954, 1969). Therefore, I briefly link my findings to the debate of the 1990s between Malkin/Wildavsky (1991, 355) on the one side, who argue that the traditional distinction between public and private goods is socially constructed and suggest abandoning this distinction and defining a public good instead ‘as one the public decides to treat as a public good’ (1991, 372), and Adams/McCormick (1993) and Cornes/Sandler (1994) on the other side, who argue that the dichotomy should not be abandoned, but extended with club goods and impure public goods. Finally, I offer a simple way for classifying actual consumption acts occurring in the real world as either rival or nonrival. This classifying procedure not only reinforces the modeling I propose in earlier sections of the paper, but is also helpful for the practical application of my findings.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


