ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The 'marginalist revolution' and Russian economic thought: Tugan-Baranovsky's synthetic approach to value theory
Author: Allisson François
The reception of marginalism in Russia is a fascinating story that still needs to be written. It started timidly in the early 1890s and became a more widely discussed topic from the beginning of the 20th century until the late 1920s. When the first echo of the 'marginalist revolution' was heard in Russia in 1890, the political economy was already under the Western influence of German historicism and of Marxism. In this context, the theory of marginal utility had a certain luck: a majority of its proponents considered it not as the right successor, but as the adequate complement to the former value theories. Russian economists like Tugan-Baranovsky (1865-1919), Dmitriev (1868-1913), Shaposhnikov (1878-1938), Yurovsky (1884-1938) and, to some extent Bilimovic (1876-1963) and the young Slutsky (1880-1948) produced various attempts to synthesise or conciliate marginal utility with labour value and or costs of production theories. In order to understand the motivations behind this synthetic current, and by way of the first chapter of this overall story, this paper offers our interpretation of the first of these attempts, namely Tugan-Baranovsky's synthetic approach to value theory. The name of Tugan-Baranovsky, when quoted by historians of price theory, is often associated with his critical contributions to Marx's theory of value (e.g. his 'revisionist' use of Marx's schemes of reproduction to invalidate the law of the tendency of the rate of profit to fall). Indeed, his "Theoretische Grundlagen des Marxismus" (1905) appears in every survey about the 'transformation problem' as an ancestor -besides Dmitriev's "Economic Essays" (1904)- to Bortkiewicz's solutions (1906-7). Tugan-Baranovsky's critical contributions put his own positive contributions in the shade. His synthesis between the labour theory of value and the marginalist theory of price is often considered to be, at best, an eclectic theory. Although his synthesis did not revolutionize economic theory, the meaning of his synthesis deserves some attention. This investigation allows us to identify an important concept in Tugan-Baranovsky's thought: the 'economic plan' (khozjajstvennyj plan), whose meaning will be specified in the paper. In particular, we interpret this concept as a go-between resolving the contradictions between value and price. The 'economic plan' also provides a key to understanding the articulation between the positive and the normative components of Tugan-Baranovsky's economic thought. This articulation explains, some decades after the 'marginalist revolution', the strong persistence in his analysis of the notion of 'value', while it has been progressively replaced elsewhere by 'prices'. Since Tugan-Baranovsky's writings on value and price theory are not well known, the first section of the paper presents the corpus under investigation. In these writings, several references are made to the synthesis, distinguishable into two broad versions: a 'simple story' often met in the literature (as a simple unexplained and lucky arithmetical example), and a more complex and less studied theory. The simple version is described using Tugan-Baranovsky's own words in section 2. The rest of the paper deals with the more complex version of the synthesis. Section 3 briefly reviews Tugan-Baranovsky's methodological position in order to further understand his notion of categories. Section 4 describes his synthesis using the distinctions he made between the categories of cost, value and price. Section 5 offers -highlighting the notion of 'economic plan'- an interpretation of the meaning of this synthesis.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


