ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The Nature of Money: History of Social Accounting System Approach
Author: Mensik Josef


The aim of this paper is to map the early history of the social accounting system approach to the nature money, identify its individual expositions and ideas expressed and try to find possible connections between them. Any economy of more than one subject -- social economy -- needs a mechanism which monitors the participation of individual agents in economic processes. In an individualistically market oriented economy this mechanism motivates individual participation in production and enforces necessary constraints on individual consumption. Such a mechanism is called social accounting system. Social accounting system takes care of individuals' contributions to the social economy and the benefits drawn by them from it, so it does nothing else but imposes the logic of budget constraints onto the reality of economic processes. So, in theoretical sense, is the social accounting system functionally identical to the operation of the mechanism of budget constraints. But the social accounting system is not a purely theoretical concept. Quite the contrary, it is the real implementation of the mechanism of budget constraints into the actual social economy what we are interested in here. And, according to the social accounting system approach to the nature of money, here rests the ontology of money: the nature and necessity of money (what is money and why does it exist) consists in the practical implementation of the social accounting system into actual social economy. Some would even say that simply money is the social accounting system. This approach to money stands in certain opposition to "money as an asset" view. That is why in the history of economic thought, is such a view of the nature of money in certain way connected with the monetary ideas of some anti-metalists (e.g. John Law), of the authors, who has identified money with a ticket or voucher (e.g. Berkeley), or later of the proponents of the "income approach" to the theory of price level (e.g. Tooke). Some authors even expressed several notions important for the social accounting system approach (e.g. J. S. Mill). But the priority of the first genuine exposition of the social accounting system approach to the nature of money the author was able to identify in the history of economic thought belongs to Bastiat. Then follow the contributions of Macleod, Wicksell, Wieser, Mitchell-Innes, Schumpeter and Hawtrey. Differences and relations between these respective approaches are analysed in the text, as well as the question of the reasons of their small impact. The paper concludes with the result, that also the social accounting approach to the nature of money did not constitute a coherent track of thoughts in the second half of 19th century and beginning of 20th century, nevertheless some monetary theorists of high repute individually came out with similar ideas about the nature of money and its major role in the social accounting processes, leaving clear hints for further development of the approach by future generations of economists.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.