ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The luxury paradox in Graslin's economic thought
Author: Jortie Etienne


This paper deals with an obscure facet of J.-J.-L. Graslin's economic thought: his analysis of the luxury issue. In 1767, Graslin publishes a book « Essai analytique sur la richesse et sur l’impôt » where he puts forward his highly personal view on political economics. His essay is a twofold work: it is both the answer to a competition which was organized few months before by the « Société Royale d’Agriculture de Limoge » and the outline of a « new economic system » that the author had been working on for many years. There is no specific treatment of the « luxury » issue in his book, e.g. there is no particular chapter about the luxury issue. But this issue is so important – and the work so ambitious – that a careful reader quickly notices that this issue is a major aspect of his analysis. At first, the reader is struck by Graslin's paradoxical stance on the luxury issue. Unlike the physiocrats, Graslin thinks that industry and trade create wealth – as agriculture does. According to him, industry and trade sectors not only add raw materials supplied by agriculture – like physiocrats think – but they also are producers themselves. Because luxury is traditionally linked to the industrial sector – the later is not sterile as asserted by the physiocrats –, Graslin logically ought to be considered an advocate of luxury, while the physiocratic link between the luxury items spending and the sterile class expenditure is no longer justified. Yet – and the paradox lies there – Graslin takes the same stand as the « sect » and comes out against luxury goods spending. To understand Graslin's stand, one should not refer to the physiocratic pattern. Graslin wants to build an alternative way of thinking and, as a matter of fact, his stand has nothing to do with the physiocrats' one. Although both systems draw the same conclusion, the arguments they put forward are basically very different. In order to understand and explain Graslin's stand, we offer a threefold framework: A) In the first place, we show the main aspects of Graslin's economic system. We especially explicit the notions of « value », « wealth » and « need » to identify the issues that luxury raises. B) In second place, we use the example given by Graslin regarding the appearance of new needs. We adapt this example to the case of luxury goods. We observe how luxury acts on « wealth order » (in and out) in order to discuss its effects on the population. We understand why what is superfluous makes it harder for men to feel satisfied and how it penalizes the wealth of nations. C) In third place, we are interested by who is at the origin of luxury expenditures, who is disadvantaged because of this spending, and to what extent it is responsible for the inequalities that settled into the society. We learn that the guilty ones are the landowners, that luxury penalizes the poorest people and that if we want to improve the situation the only answer is promoting more equality (notably via a fairer tax system). Eventually, we discover an original view on luxury; J.-J. Rousseau-like philosophers' stand may thus be economically justified by Graslin's theory.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.