ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: On Sen and Aristotle
Author: Crespo Ricardo


The history of the connections of Sen and Aristotle has to do with Sen’s relations with Martha Nussbaum. Virtually every quote or reference to Aristotle includes a reference to Nussbaum. In his “Autobiography” Sen affirms that he worked closely with her during 1987-9. He recognizes that at the time of proposing the new approach (CA), in 1979, he did not manage to seize its Aristotelian connections. He then refers to the work of Nussbaum on this connection. The first written reference to Aristotle in relation to the capability approach and to Nussbaum time is in the pre-publication on line of Sen’s Tanner Lectures 1985, in 1986 (Clare Hall, Cambridge, March, 11-2, 1985). Later quotations of Aristotle are from the Nicomachean Ethics (NE, especially Book I, Chapter 7) and Politics. Sen begins the first Chapter of On Ethics and Economics (1987) arguing that Economics has had two different origins. One of them is the ethics-related tradition that goes back to Aristotle. Sen, in a chapter of a book he edited with Nussbaum, though recognizing that he was not aware of this before, notes that the Greek word dynamin, used by Aristotle to discuss an aspect of the human good can be translated as ‘capability of existing or acting’. In his Tanner Lectures 1985, he also quotes Aristotle (together with Plato and Mill) about incommensurability. Consequently, he concludes, we need a “constitutive plurality”. He applies this characteristic to capabilities. In this paper I will show that Sen agrees with Aristotle 1) in his conception of the relation between Economics, Ethics and Politics; 2) in his conception about the role of wealth and possessions in a Good Life, 3) in his conception of eudaimonia and 4) about the need to examine the process of choosing the activities that constitute or contribute to eudaimonia. Sen also perceives a connection between his concept of “functionings” and the Aristotelian concept of ergon and between his concept of capabilities and the Aristotelian concept of dynamis. Finally, Sen agrees with Aristotle in the consideration of the non-commensurability or heterogeneity of goods. Concerning differences, Sen does not accept the supposedly Aristotelian conception of a unique objective list of functionings and capabilities supported by Nussbaum. In the paper I will argue that these Aristotelian influences on Sen’s ideas have helped him to define and refine his Capability Approach and the practical consequences of it.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.