ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Liberal economic discourse on colonial practices and the rejection of the British Empire (1750-1815)
Author: CLEMENT Alain


In the mid-18th century, Great Britain had a very large colonial empire, especially since the Treaty of 1763. But the independence of the thirteen colonies, given by England in the Treaty of Versailles in 1783, broke up the British presence on this large continent with its 4 million inhabitants. All that remained by the end of the century were Nova Scotia and Canada. At the turn of the century, production by the colonial economy was roughly equivalent to 4% of the British economy and 33% at the end of the century. Colonial production was exclusively exported to England, although the system allowed for some leeway. England’s sales to its colonies were twice that of its purchases from the latter. At the end of the 18th century, 2/3 of its transactions were with America, Asia and Africa, as against 1/5 in 1700. England also became wealthy via triangular trade throughout the century. In spite of this solid performance – before becoming a pitfall for the economic growth of England (Etemad, 2005) – economists of the second half of the century would not only criticize the old colonial system, but some of them would also declare relinquishment of the colonies to be necessary, or at least suggest this implicitly. For economists of the first half of this century (Gee, 1729; Defoe, 1728; Decker, 1744; Gervaise, 1720; Lindsay, 1733), the colonies still represented an El Dorado and a major market, although these authors did begin to challenge the old colonial system. In the second half of the century, with economists such as Smith (1776), Bentham (1790, 1793, 1801-1804) Anderson (1782) and Tucker (1752, 1755, 1776, 1781), and with other public figures the likes of Burke (1777, 1783) and Colquhoun (1814), criticism was recurrent and insistent, and some of them suggested the abandonment of the empire. The benefits of colonisation were criticized for three reasons: first, it constituted a private benefit granted to merchants (criticism of mercantilism); second, it was a benefit by default (good results obtained only when colonial policy is not applied entirely); third, it was a benefit for the colonies and other foreign countries, but not for the mother country. Economic costs were the main argument against the colonial empire. The question posed was the following: Are the colonies of benefit to the mother country? A first examination looks at exclusive trade, esteemed as being little profitable to Great Britain (Winch, 1965, 1996; Platteau, 1978), even if profitable to a certain social class. It weakened the economy by creating a differentiation between European trade and extra-European trade, artificially favouring the latter (Anderson, 1782). Moreover, trade was less developed than it would have been if the colonies did not exist. It redirected investments from their natural course in favour of more high risk investments with longer times to returns (Smith). This policy produced more artificial advantages for colonial trade (Smith, Bentham), it weakened the economy by encouraging trade to the detriment of domestic affairs, especially agriculture and industry (Smith, 1776), and lengthened the economic circuit. These authors also criticized the role played by the chartered companies, a symbol of exclusive trade, especially in relations with trading posts in India (see in particular the East India Company) whose monopoly yielded no benefits, either to the colony or to the mother country (Burke, Tucker and Smith). The second point concerned the costs engendered by the internal functioning of the colonies and their consequences on the mother country. Colonisation was expensive because of expenditures for operations, defence and protection. These expenditures were particularly high, given colonised countries the size of America. Costs were magnified by a low population density. This cost was all the more burdensome as the colonised countries did not contribute and refused to contribute to their financing (see Anderson, Colquhoun, Smith, and Tucker). The development of the colonies required more manual labour, and therefore substantial migration, which created a loss of population in the mother country. Finally, colonisation yields poor development, not only for the mother country but also for the colonies themselves. In the long run, the prohibitions imposed represented economic oppression such that growth of these areas was not optimal. However, the colonies produced an excellent opportunity for all countries. They offered new goods and new markets (Smith), but these benefits could be achieved even if the colonies were independent and enjoyed economic and politic freedom. If the results were positive, this was due to noncompliance with and moderation in the application of colonial policy. It could even be said that, if the colonies were independent, the benefits to all countries would be considerable, as compared to current situation at the time. Consequently, the solutions proposed were along the lines of renunciation of the colonial empire. This is relatively clear in the writings of Bentham, Burke, Anderson and Tucker; it is less so in Smith’s analysis, in which he suggests not independence (for political reasons) but free trade between the colonies and the mother country. In any case, the colonies did not represent the El Dorado claimed by the authors of the 17th century and early 18th century.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.