ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Expertise as Attribution
Author: Jimenez-Buedo Maria


(To be included in the proposed session: The Economist as Expert) In recent years, the nature of expert judgment and the role of the expert in the policy making process is becoming an issue of growing importance for several strands of literature that reflect upon the nature of social science knowledge and collective decision making processes (Collins and Evans 2007, Selinger and Crease 2006, Tetlock 2007, Kurz-Milcke and Gigerenzer 2004). One of the most important contributions in this re-emerging of the interest in expertise is Collins and Evans’ research program recently launched under the rubric of Studies on Expertise and Experience. This project, aiming at correcting past constructivist excesses in the Sociology of Knowledge, puts an emphasis in what the authors call a realist interpretation of expertise, in detriment of the relational and attributional dimensions of the phenomenon of the expert. According to C&E, previous accounts of expertise have allowed for a watering down of the notion of expertise, in that a minimalist definition of it has been normally accepted: an expert is that for whom a given constituency considers him or her so. Opposing this view, C&E insist in that expertise is a real capacity acquired via socialization in a given relevant community and that an expert is so independently of whether other actors think of his or her capacities: C&E’s main aim is actually that of classifying different types of expertise, according to the relative number of those who possess it and also, according to the capacities with which it enables the expert (as in the ability to directly participate in a given practice versus the ability to assess the performance of others at that given practice). While the classificatory exercise of C&E constitutes an interesting contribution, the contention of this paper is that the most relevant aspect of the study of expertise has to do, precisely, with its relational and attributional dimensions. Without implying that expertise is an exhaustively relational phenomenon, as some have claimed (Fuller 2006), I argue that unless the attributional character of expertise is underlined, there is the risk of re-visiting, under the newly appealing rubric of expertise, old questions long-pursued in epistemology, about the nature of scientific and technological knowledge. To defend this claim, the paper reviews some well-known contributions in Comparative Political Economy (Hall 1989, Haas 1992, Blyth 2002), that have studied how the impact of experts on policy is maximal at times of political and economic crises, when politicians and state actors are unsure of their own interests and experts can help define them. It is in those cases in which the question of why some experts are favoured over others for reasons that cannot be fully explained by their degree of (or in C&E’s terms, real) expertise becomes more relevant, or in other words, it is the study of the conditions under which the status of expert is attributed, that becomes crucial to explain policy outcomes. References: Blyth, M. 2002. Great Transformations: Economic Ideas and Institutional Change in the Twentieth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Collins H. and R. Evans. 2007. Rethinking Expertise. Chicago: Chicago University Press. Fuller, 2006. The Constitutively Social Character of Expertise. In The Philosophy of Expertise, Selinger, E. and Crease, R.(eds). New York: Columbia University Press. Haas, P. Knowledge, Power and International Policy Coordination. 1992. International Organization. Vol 46. No.1. Special Issue. Hall, P. 1989. Keynesianism across nations. The political power of economic ideas.. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press Kurz-Milcke, E. And Gigerenzer, G. 2004. Experts in Science and Society. New York: Kluwer. Selinger, E. and Crease, R. 2006. The Philosophy of Expertise. New York: Columbia University Press. Tetlock, P. 2005. Expert Judgment. How good is it? How can we know? NJ: Princeton University Press

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.