ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Mill and the homo oeconomicus
Author: Gillig Philippe


It is a commonplace, currently, among sociologists and anthropologists (at least since, Polanyi, Godelier or Dumont) to deplore the fact that economics is based on a moral philosophy of private interest or on this central actor called “homo oeconomicus”. What is stigmatised is an insufficient conception of man and of its motivations. However, it is troubling to point out that one of the first theoretician who has tried to justify the necessity for economics to be based on such a narrow conception of man, that is to say John Stuart Mill, does not say anything else than the anthropologists. Indeed, he explicitly underlines the anthropological weakness of this “invented” actor. Why, nonetheless, does he put the stress on an “economic man” (another traditionally used term in English economic literature) when he comes to found political economy? The reading of his texts shows clearly, as we will see, that it is strictly for epistemological reasons. If therefore one wants to undertake a criticism of the homo oeconomicus, it seems not very relevant to criticise its lack of realism. Mill does it himself immediately and underlines how it is obvious. What is necessary to examine is the epistemological justification given by Mill. In other words, it is necessary to substitute for traditional anthropological criticism an epistemological criticism.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.