ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The Role of Experts in the Epistemology of Economics
Author: Martini Carlo


[to be included in the session “The Economista s Expert” (with Maria Jimenez-Buedo, David Teira, Julian Reiss)] A great deal of knowledge that is produced in the social sciences relies on expert judgement. The role of experts is, however, controversial: for instance, in economics, experts are often seen as an external element to the science itself; according to Milton Friedman, experts belong to the "art of economics", as opposed to the "science of economics". Experts are normally characterized by imprecise judgment and lack of scientific precision, but are destined to be eliminated by the development of economics as a science, and to leave the room to purely scientific methods, such as modeling and theory construction. This, at least, was Friedman's prediction in his 1953 paper, "The Methodology of Positive Economics". My paper provides an assessment of Friedman's statements in the light of the development of economics from the times of Friedman to its present state of the art. The paper analyzes two well-known families of models in economics and sociology, the Segregation Models and the Rational Addiction Models. There is already a considerable amount of literature on both these models, however, the approach that will be taken in this paper deviates from previous lines of research, insofar as it considers predictive power and practical knowledge as a desideratum, before any other analysis of the possible causal links between a model and the world. In this respect, one of the core principles that Friedman (1953) assumes (methodological instrumentalism) is also assumed here, whereas most of the critiques on the adequacy of economic modeling start from very different ground assumptions (for instance Hausman (1992), Maki (1994), Sugden (2000), and others). Even by its own standards, nonetheless, Friedman's idea that modeling can replace the role of experts does not seem feasible at the present state of the art in economics, nor at any foreseeable future state. Rational addiction models and segregation models are not only practically incapable of providing the type of knowledge that is normally required from an economic expert, in the policy making arena, but are also in principle inadequate for such a task. This paper concludes by providing a brief overview on the role of experts in economics and by suggesting alternative paths towards exactness and precision in economics, other than modeling alone. Main Bibliography: - Becker, Gary S., Michael Grossman and Kevin M. Murphy (1994). "An Empirical Analysis of Cigarette Addiction." The American Economic Review, Vol. 84 (3):396-418. - Friedman, Milton (1953). "Essays in Positive Economics". Chicago: University of Chicago Press. - Hausman, Daniel M. (1992). "The Inexact and Separate Science of Economics". Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. - Schelling, Thomas (1971). "Dynamic Models of Segregation." Journal of Mathematical Sociology, 1: 143-186. - Sugden, Robert (2000). "Credible Worlds: the Status of Theoretical Models in Economics." Journal of Economic Methodology, 7(1): 1-31. - Uskali, Maki (1994). "Isolation, Idealization and Truth in Economics." Poznan Studies in the Philosophy of the Sciences and the Humanities, 38: 147-168.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.