ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: ADAM SMITH’S THEORY AND PRACTICE OF IRONY
Author: CREMASCHI Sergio


Adam Smith’s apparently did not make any special room for irony in his Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles Lettres, and yet he treated in some detail ‘Wit’, a peculiar figure in the British tradition of rhetoric. According to Smith, the Comic in general consists in representing what is in most respects Grand or pretends to be so has something mean or little in it. Wit consists in exposing to our view in a ridiculous light real foibles and blemishes in the Characters or behaviour of men; it is the kind of comic appropriate to the character of a Gentleman as it tends to the reformation of manners and the benefit of mankind. Has Adam Smith’s view of the comic and wit anything to do with his overall system of ideas, and in more detail with his ethics and his economic theory? My tentative answer is yes. The link between Smith’s rhetoric and his system in general is his post-sceptical theory of knowledge, according to which the final outcome of our mental processes is the one postulated by the rationalists while the sources of those mental processes are precisely those pointed at by the sceptics. In more detail: knowledge is according to Smith nothing but classification of phenomena by similarity and contiguity plus construction of invisible chains or imaginary machines to fill in the gaps felt by our imagination in the classification we are able to carry about. Ethics is just a collection of customary rules resulting from numberless cases of sympathetic approval or disapproval of actions, emotions, and characters and then made systematic by connecting rules to some more general kind of principle. And yet, neither in science nor in morality “everything goes”. In both fields there are more plausible and less plausible doctrines, and our imagination feels compelled to conform with the most plausible ones, since they are simpler, more consistent, more beautiful, and leave less gaps in the phenomena. Also in Adam Smith’s economic theory the issue is eliminating mistaken ideas arising from passions and aware deceptions by self-interested and unfair actors such as “merchants and master-manufacturers” by showing how these arise from unjustified association of ideas, joining things that are apparently great, such as national power, and rather ‘mean’ things such as the merchants’ own interests. The final result is no new theoretical system, but instead an anti-system, the “simple and obvious” system of natural liberty. Smith’s overall intellectual strategy is accordingly, in both his main works, a ‘dialectical’ and ‘dialogical’ one, in so far as it is aimed at unmasking false claims embedded in ‘systems’ that impose themselves to human imagination by a feigned ‘greatness’ of theoretical principles while what actually lays behind such principles is only the ‘meanness’ of selfish interests or of lack of intellectual modesty. This intellectual strategy – I dare to say - is basically what ‘wit’ was meant to be in Smith’s Lectures on Rhetoric and the ‘ironical’ destiny of Adam Smith was that of being praised or attacked as the spokesman of Capitalism, or of those ‘merchants and master-manufacturers’ whose characters’ ‘foibles and blemishes’ he intended to expose.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.