ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Economic Metaphors in the Goudriaan-Tinbergen debate on dynamics and equilibrium
Author: Rodenburg Peter
The academic debate in the Netherlands on the economic crisis of the 1930s can be characterized as a continuing debate on the very nature of economics between two leading Dutch economists, Jan Goudriaan (1893-1974) and Jan Tinbergen (1903-1994). This paper inquires this debate on dynamics and equilibrium, between Goudriaan and Tinbergen, and focuses on the role metaphors played in this debate and the ensuing consequences for economic policies. In response to continuing economic crisis of the 1930s both Jan Goudriaan and Jan Tinbergen formulated specific theoretical views on the working of the economy. Though Goudriaan and Tinbergen shared the same political ideas they very much disagreed on the nature of equilibrium and dynamics. Both economists worked out their ideas on business cycles and dynamics in a systematic approach. The essence of Goudriaan’s approach is that economics dynamics is fundamentally unstable and that, as a consequence, prices are undetermined. Goudriaan coined (in 1952) the term ‘analytical economics’ for his anti-deterministic approach to economics. Tinbergen on the other hand favoured a probabilistic approach for his econometric method. Underlying their views on the economy, however, are different metaphors for the economy: Goudriaan’s “collapsing bridge” vs. Tinbergen’s “pendulum with friction”. The different metaphors have far-reaching consequences for their respective economic policies. The purpose of this paper is twofold. It will try to provide a historical account of the debate on equilibrium and dynamics in the Netherlands by focusing on the contributions of Goudriaan and Tinbergen. It will investigate why Goudriaan’s ‘analytical economics’ never gained much ground in the Netherlands. Secondly, it will try to provide a methodological analysis of the role the different metaphors played and their consequences for economic policy in the Netherlands.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


