ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: An individualistic bias in behavioral economics: as regards its notions of reference, context and default
Author: Hong Hoon, LEE Kyu Sang


This paper argues that behavioral economics (BE) as initiated by Kahneman and Tversky offers, at least, three different accounts of its central notions, i.e., reference, default and context (RCD). The three might be termed individualistic, descriptive and social. Inclined towards individualism, BE conceives RCD as arising from relations or ratios between alternatives for choice on the part of an individual rather than from comparisons or relations between humans. Objects of choice range from an array of (bundles of) goods on an indifference map, through a list of prices and qualities for a specific product (e.g., a computer), to a set of possible rulings in a court. Thus BE subscribes to the view that an individual's indifference map is more than the sum of its goods in disapproval of the axiom of independence of alternatives. But at the same time it rules out the possibility that a society could be more than the sum of its individuals. This implies that BE seems to share methodological individualism with neoclassical economics, despite their disagreement upon the behavioral postulate of rationality. Whereas this individualistic account seems to rely upon a given set of goods, there is also a descriptive account in BE which, drawing upon a set of words, highlights verbal or numerical representation of choice situation. While the former seems to explicate endowment effects, the second unravels framing effects. However, as this descriptive account couches RCD in terms of a static description of a situation, it neglects both pragmatic heuristics to solve adaptive problems and interpersonal communication or dynamic interactions between parties. Finally, some proponents of BE, albeit infrequently, formulate RCD in a social setting. Sunstein relies upon a socio-political account for the explication of the role of a default in wage bargaining between management and labour. This social account is prone to specify RCD in terms of entitlements (i.e., rights) rather than in terms of endowments (i.e., goods and resources), because entitlements, unlike endowments, presuppose the existence of a society and social relations between humans. It is in line with studies on marketing which imply possible conflicts of (enlightened) interests between consumers and a firm, depending upon whether choice situation takes on an opt-out or an opt-in form (e.g., for the sale of cars, insurance, or pizzas). Moreover, it is endorsed by such ideas as Akerlof's and Frank's socio-cultural concepts of reference wages, relative income and positional goods. This third account seems to provide the basis for a more coherent and reliable rendition of RCD in that it makes allowances for interpersonal communication and dynamic interactions as well as pragmatic settings.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.