ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Ottoman Economic Thinking in the Light of Humorism (Ahlat-i Erbaa)
Author: ERMIS Fatih


How did the Ottomans interpret economic issues? The answer to this question lies in the integrality of economic relations in the whole social structure. The application of the humor theory to the social context, first by Katib Çelebi and then by Naima, helps us to understand this holistic view. In this theory, which is in its origin a medical theory, the state is depicted as an organic creature. We may in fact speak of a general tendency in Middle Eastern traditions to see states like organic creatures. The most notable representative of this approach is Ibn Khaldun. Humorism is an enhancement of this approach a few steps forward. It is based on an analogy between the four humors of human body (blood, yellow bile, black bile, phlegm) and the four groups of a society (scholars, merchants, peasants, bureaucrats). The medical version of humorism can be found at the ancient Greece. It is plausible, however, to assume that Naima took this theory from Muslim physicians and especially from Avicenna (Ibn Sina). The contribution of Avicenna to humorism was the integration of temperaments with humorism. Within the framework of humorism, the main pillar of the social order appears to be a balance between the above mentioned four groups. The concept of balance is also closely related with the perception of justice and also with the idea of the circle of justice. The underlying idea of the above mentioned analogy is that as the health of the body depends upon the balance of the four humors, the “health” of a society depends similarly on the balance of the four constituting groups of the society. A one-to-one correspondence is constructed between scholars – blood, merchants – yellow bile, peasants – black bile, bureaucrats – phlegm in this analogy. And for each institution or structure of society too a functionally corresponding organ or characteristic of human body is mentioned: Treasury – stomach, money – food, money-changers – tastes, finance officers – attraction, bookkeepers – ability of digest … etc. Our concern in this paper will be to shed some light on the interpretation of economic relations by the Ottoman intellectuals between different layers of society basing upon humorism.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.