ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Institutions and the theory of cognition in Proudhon
Author: SOLARI Stefano


Even if in Proudhon there is no direct explicit emphasis on institutions, there is no doubt on the deep affinity between his system of thought and XX century American institutionalism (Gurvitch ,1965). Besides the faith in the possibility of positive effect of collective action on economic performance and, above all, on the distribution of income, the most remarkable similarity resides in the epistemology of this theoretical framework. As a consequence we can highlight the surprising similarity between the research programme outlined by Proudhon in the Création de l’Ordre and the Quest for Certainty of Dewey. Both theories insist on the distinctive analysis of regulating mechanisms by assuming a relevant ethical position on them, without any economic fundamentalism. In both cases we find applications of modern “Practical reason” approach applied to social order. However, while institutionalism based its ethical principle on the open discussion and democracy, Proudhon epistemology introduces other aspects as equality and justice. It follows that the law tend to be instrumental for institutionalism while in Proudhon it is based on morals and an expression of justice. The consequence is that, looking at practical outcomes of this theorisation, institutionalism also departed from the line of Proudhon because of a renewed faith in the action of the government. That explains how in Proudhon we find a theory of “federalism”, “soft law” and the clearest expression of the principle of “check and balances” while institutionalism focused mainly on top-down institutional change. The heritage of Proudhon is therefore fragmented according to many of his ideas, but few followed his epistemology. We can underline how little follow-up and understanding he enjoyed between economists, probably because of his epistemology. The paper, after comparing the epistemologies of Dewey and Proudhon, studies the idea of institution emerging from Proudhon’s works. Finally the idea of economic regulation is compared in Proudhon and in the North American institutionalism.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.