ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Say’s Law and Clément Juglar Business Cycles analysis
Author: DAL-PONT Muriel


If one can consider Say’s law as a largely accepted concept by the the XIX° century French Liberal School, a more serious investigation may show that this community was perhaps much more heterogenous than it may appear. One peculiar case within the large range of French Liberal economists of that period is Clément Juglar (1819-1905). Indeed there are many reasons to consider Juglar as a singular figure. His training as a physician (cf. Frobert and Hamouda [2008] , his moral deeply rooted in his religious faith (cf. Dal-Pont Legrand and Frobert [2006]) are two elements which deeply influenced his approach of political economy. Certainly that his (over-)commitments to data analysis and his reluctance to trust pure theoretical approaches are other important elements which did not facilitate his integration among the French liberal school. Indeed, Juglar was very often criticized by his colleagues who did not hesitate to consider him as the “Prophète des crises” (cf? Courcelle-Seneuil [1889]). One can also notice that if Juglar is still considered as the founding author of the modern business cycles theory his contribution to business cycles analysis was not at the origin of any kind of “school” : certainly that his relatively isolated position within the liberal school partly explains his weak influence on the political economy of his times. The purpose of that paper is to focus on Juglar’s theoretical approach of business cycles and to consider the status he attributed there to Say’s law. He first seems to consider that the rejection of Say’s law as a pure empirical question: theoretically Say’s law works but concrete imperfect markets can nevertheless generate general gluts. But when Juglar seriously investigates monetary Theory, we can show that his rejection of Say’s law is no more ambiguous: for Juglar, a credit economy is by definition uncompatible with Say’s law "les affaires au comptant ne peuvent jamais les (les crises) produire" (1863 p.2). Elements of Bibliography COURCELLE-SENEUIL [1889], recension de l’ouvrage de clément Juglar de 1889, Journal des économistes, octobre 1889, P. 446-451. DAL-PONT LEGRAND M. [2006], "Credit in Juglar analysis of business cycles", ESHET Annual Conference, 27th - 29th April, Porto, Portugal. DAL-PONT LEGRAND M. AND L. FROBERT [2006], “On the relationship between Religion, Economics and Political discourses. Clément Juglar, ‘prophète des crises’”, AISPE Conference, 15-17 Juin, Padoue, Italie. LUDOVIC FROBERT AND OMAR HAMOUDA, “The influence of medicine in Clément Juglar’s first take of economic cycles », Journal of History of Economic Thought, vol. March 2008. JUGLAR C. [1863], “Crises commerciales”, Extrait du dictionnaire général de la politique by M. Maurice Block, Strasbourg. JUGLAR C. [1868], Du change et de la liberté d'émission, publié par Guillaumin et Cie, paris. Réédité par Elibron Classics series en 2003. JUGLAR C. [1889], Des crises commerciales et de leur retour périodique en France, en Angleterre et aux Etats-Unis, Paris : Guillaumin et Cie, librairies. JUGLAR C. [1898], “Le rôle de la statistique au point de vue historique et au point de vue économique”, Paris, Editions Alphonse Picard et fils. JUGLAR C. [1899], “ Le besoin de croire”, Bulletin de la ligue nationale contre l’athéisme, 18 pages.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.