ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Reconciling commerce & virtue: Recovering a lost tradition in economics in Adam Smith and the Oriel Noetics.
Author: Douglas Elena
Reconciling commerce & virtue: Recovering a lost tradition in economics in Adam Smith and the Oriel Noetics. Elena Pasquini Douglas, University of Western Australia This paper intends to contribute threads in the fabric of a lost tradition of commercial society being reconciled with and conducive to virtue. The paper considers the recent presentation of Adam Smith as a virtue ethicist (McCloskey 2008, Vivenza 2001) and other work which recovers the founder of capitalism and economics’ diagnosis of the psychological, social and ethical ills flowing from commercial societies, as well as his prescriptions for their amelioration (Hanley 2009, Sen 2010). Remedies included the cultivation of the virtues of prudence, magnanimity and beneficence outlined in a newly drafted chapter On the Character of Virtue in the sixth edition of the Theory of Moral Sentiments (1959) newly examined by Ryan Patrick Hanley (Hanley 2009). The paper presents Smith as a critic of capitalism’s negative impacts and a proponent of virtue as their remedy. After introducing this recent literature on Smith and virtue, the Oriel Noetics are introduced including a brief biographical sketch of Richard Whately, Noetic intellectual leader based at Oriel College, Oxford from 1811-1831. The paper then builds on the growing secondary literature on Whately’s role in the emergence of political economy as a distinct science from its natural theology and moral philosophy origins (Moore & White 2009; A.M.C. Waterman 1991b; Waterman 2008; Levy 1999; Levy & Peart 2010; Hilton 1986; Corsi 1988; Oslington 2001; Rashid 1977) to present a brief sketch of Noetic political philosophy, in advance of the Noetic Political Economy which ultimately flowed from it (Douglas 2013). The paper then identifies continuities and discontinuities between the Smith and the Oriel Noetic approach in relation to the following questions: (i) the purpose or telos of a commercial society; (ii) the relationship between commerce and virtue; (iii) the relationship between wealth and virtue; and (iv) moral dangers in commercial society. Finally the paper poses some preliminary reflections on the role of the history of economic thought in contributing to the current debate between virtue ethicists and critics of modernity, and economists. This debate has elements of ongoing antagonism (Macintyre, 1981, 2007; Sandel 2010) and early rapproachment (Bruni & Sugden 2012). Whately’s reconciliation of commercial society and virtue are presented as elements of a way forward in resolving questions of morality and markets and the moral competence and prospects of commercial societies.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)