ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Lutz and Equilibrium business-cycle theories
Author: DAL-PONT LEGRAND Muriel, HAGEMANN Harald
In modern debates on relevant historical roots of equilibrium business-cycle theories reference is normally made to Hayek who defended the equilibrium method against claims by Lowe (endorsed by Kuznets) to abandon it in the analysis of business cycles as an essentially disequilibrium phenomenon. Lucas himself in his “Understanding Business Cycles” (1977: 7) had indicated Hayek as an important precursor of his ideas. In this debate on the (in)compatibility of business-cycle theory with the theory of general economic equilibrium the contribution by Friedrich A. Lutz (1901 – 1975) had been widely overlooked, although Lutz was a well-known economist with international reputation in monetary, capital, and interest theory. After his emigration from Nazi Germany in 1938 Lutz made an academic career in Princeton before he moved to Zurich, Switzerland in 1953. In his Das Konjunkturproblem in der Nationalökonomie (The Problem of Business Cycles in Economics), of which the core parts were only published in an English translation in 2002, Lutz got his habilitation from the University of Freiburg in 1932. In this book Lutz was a strong defender of the prevailing equilibrium approach by denying the need for the development of a general theory of the business cycle since the business cycle does not exist and the real problem of analysing concrete-historical cases of fluctuations with a variety of different factures at work, could be completely dealt with within the framework of a modern static equilibrium approach. The analysis of changes in the data, which is the task of business-cycle theory, could be done completely within the existing framework of equilibrium theory by the use of the variation method. According to Lutz there would be no need for a ‘new dynamic’ theory as had been claimed by Lowe who had got major inspiration from Schumpeter’s distinction between statics and dynamics. For Lutz the introduction of technical progress, as favoured by Schumpeter and Lowe, is nothing else than a change in the data which would lead to a new equilibrium. Lutz only concedes that equilibrium theory, particularly due to the influence of the Lausanne school, had not put enough emphasis on adjustment processes. However, static theory also includes the “investigation of how equilibrium comes about, that is, the movement towards equilibrium following a change in data” (Lutz 1932: 121). Interestingly, despite Lutz’s critique of Schumpeter (including the latter’s denouncing the great majority of entrepreneurs to be “mere managers”), Schumpeter in his History of Economic Analysis (1954: 739, n.1) recognized the high analytical level of Lutz’s study of the business-cycle problem. We therefore investigate Lutz’s Konjunkturproblem in der Nationalökonomie (1932) as an important contribution on the origins of modern equilibrium business-cycle theories.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)