ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The impact of the German Historical School on the evolution of economics in Austria
Author: CHALOUPEK Günther
The relationship of the German Historical School (GHS) and economics in Austria (in the sense of the German speaking parts of the Austrian monarchy before World War I, thereafter Austria in its present form) is quite a special one. On the one hand, one would expect that German speaking economists would be susceptible to influences from the GHS, all the more so, since most German speaking Austrians considered them part of the greater German people, and also because the policy of appointments for university chairs in Staatswissenschaften after 1850 favoured academics from the Reich. But after the publication of Menger’s Grundsätze (1871) economics in Austria increasingly developed its own identity by differentiating itself from the GHS. Clearly, by World War I the Austrian School of economics came to dominate academic economics in Austria. If the influence of historicism in Austria is comparatively small, Austrian authors of the HS have produced a large number of studies in the economic history of the Habsburg monarchy, and also on issues of social policy. Besides that, there is the difficult case of Joseph Schumpeter, whose theoretical orientation is definitely Austrian, but who nonetheless aimed at a synthesis of both schools. The HS had a late start in Austrian in 1868 with the appointment of Theodor Inama von Sternegg (1843-1908) to the chair of state science at the University of Innsbruck, 1880 University of Prague. In 1881, Inama-Sternegg left his academic post and became head of Austria’s statistical office. He represented a kind of unity of theory and practice similar to the German “academics of the chair” (Kathedersozialisten). His main field of research was economic history (3-volume Deutsche Wirtschaftsgeschichte 1879-1901). He was equally concerned with issues of poor relief and social policy. Better known is Carl Grünberg (1861-1940). habilitated 1893 at the University of Strassburg by G.F. Knapp, professor at Vienna University 1899. Grünberg did extensive studies in agricultural history (systems of land tenure), advocated agricultural and social reforms. Grünberg’s theoretical background was Marxist. In contrast to the GHS, the political orientation of Austrian historicist writings is not anti-Smithian or anti-liberal, there is no predilection for medieval craft gilds. A survey of writings of historicist Austrian authors also shows a difference in political perspective between the HS in Austria and Germany. Austrian authors were caught in an ambivalence between “greater-German” nationalism (grossdeutschem Nationalismus) and a subliminally anti-German Reichsidee which viewed the Habsburg monarchy in a historical context different from Schmoller’s Hohenzollern state. In 1926 Schumpeter published his article on Schmoller where he discussed the relationship between theory and history from a principal perspective. He emphasized that theory and history were complementary, and not contradictory approaches to the understanding of economic phenomena. Schumpeter intended to make his book “Business Cycles” (published 1939)to become a model for a synthesis between the two approaches.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)