ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Galiani's theory of money
Author: Costabile Lilia


Galiani’s theory of money by Lilia Costabile The eighteenth-century Italian economist Ferdinando Galiani is considered by many as one of the founding fathers of modern monetary theory, but there is no consensus on how his theory of money should be interpreted. Schumpeter described him as an “uncompromising” metallist (Schumpeter, History of Economic Analysis, London, George Allen& Unwin, 1954, p.300). By contrast, other interpreters have argued that Galiani is better understood as a theoretical cartalist and a practical metallist, meaning that he considered the value of money as independent from the “intrinsic” value of the metallic commodity, although he adhered to the policy principle that the monetary unit should be kept linked to gold and silver (F. Cesarano, “Monetary theory in Ferdinando Galiani’s Della Moneta”, History of Political Economy, 1976; see also R.Patalano and R.Realfonzo, “On Money by Ferdinando Galiani: notes, social accounting and confidence”, History of Economic Ideas, 2001). Others conclude that Galiani incoherently oscillated between the two positions (theoretical metallism and theoretical cartalism). A clue towards a possible solution is provided by Rosselli, who argues, interestingly, that “Any attempt to classify Galiani as a cartalist or metallist is clearly doomed to failure, either because the terms of classification are too poor or because his representation of the economy is too rich” (A.Rosselli, “The role of the precious metals in Della Moneta by Ferdinando Galiani”, History of Economic Ideas, 2001, p. 58; also Rosselli, Economie et Société, Forthcoming). I argue that the distinction between theoretical cartalism and theoretical metallism is misleading when applied to Galiani. I interpret his monetary theory as a logically coherent, integrated whole. The basic elements of my interpretation are: (i) he developed the theoretical models of two different monetary economies, respectively using a commodity money and a fiduciary money; (ii) both types of money absolve the function of a “common pledge” (entitling their owners to an amount of commodities equal to the one given up in the exchange); (iii) their ability to do so depends on the common principle of general acceptability (i.e. liquidity) which, however, is based on different determinants for the two types of money; (iv) Galiani’s theory is extremely useful for clarifying the strengths and fragilities of monetary economies under alternative institutional settings (when only metallic money exists, and when fiduciary money is issued by a developed banking system). (v) An historical example concludes and clarifies the argument.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.