ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: All but one: How pioneers of linear economics overlooked Perron-Frobenius mathematics
Author: Parys Wilfried
Linear models of the input-output type (“Leontief-Sraffa models”) became an important tool of economic analysis in the 20th century. At least ten Nobel laureates (Leontief, Frisch, Simon, Koopmans, Samuelson, Arrow, Solow, Debreu, Hicks, Stone) published on similar linear models. A crucial analytical tool for these models is provided by the theory of nonnegative matrices, developed in the period 1907-1912 by Oskar Perron and Georg Frobenius. The seminal texts on linear economics in the 1910s and 1920s were written by Charasoff, Potron, Bray and Remak. All four were mathematicians, and all but Potron overlooked the usefulness of Perron-Frobenius. By combining insights from relevant archives, and from the literature on the history of mathematics and economics, I try to explain how pioneers of linear economics overlooked Perron-Frobenius mathematics. Although some of Charasoff’s mathematical interests (irreducibility, continued fractions) were close to Perron’s interests, Perron-Frobenius matrices were never explicitly used by Charasoff. Probably he just assumed that the properties of his numerical examples with three commodities also hold in the general case with n commodities. Robert Remak presented his mathematical system of superposed prices in 1929, twelve years after the death of Frobenius (his doctoral supervisor). Instead of using the efficient Perron-Frobenius tools, Remak provided lengthy proofs of his own, and directed most of his mathematical efforts to price systems in which the most important commodities have zero prices. A few years earlier, in 1922, Bray also had overlooked Perron-Frobenius in a mathematically similar model that studied Cournot’s equations of currency exchange. I provide archival evidence that Leontief knew Remak’s results already in the early 1930s, before he submitted a theoretical paper on his input-output model to the Economic Journal in 1933. Keynes rejected Leontief’s paper. A few years later Leontief published his theoretical and empirical (Nobel prize winning) results in American journals. Just like Leontief, Sraffa started related research in the late 1920s. He didn’t discuss his mathematical problems with competent economic colleagues in Cambridge or in the Econometric Society, but he preferred help from three non-economists: Ramsey, Watson and especially Besicovitch. I suggest that Besicovitch in a forgotten 1918 paper “came close” to Perron-Frobenius results, but it is well-known that he didn’t know the old Perron-Frobenius papers, and invented his own proofs for Sraffa in the 1940s. We should see a scholar’s work in its context. Results or connections that seem obvious today were not trivial for the pioneers.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)