ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Economics without foundation Galiani’s Dialogues sur le commerce des blés
Author: Tonneau Olivier
Session: Historical Political Economy Author: Olivier Tonneau « Artists do not know what they are doing », Marcel Duchamp once wrote. According to Ferdinando Galiani, neither do economists. In 1770, he submitted the theories of the physiocrats (who coined the famous expression « laissez-faire ») to a scathing criticism. The controversy between the économistes and Galiani has far-reaching implications for the very nature of economics as a science. Whereas the économistes made a point of constructing models without any reference to a given empirical context, Galiani brilliantly exposed their « axiomatic fallacy »: the économistes’ theories do have a referential context (namely that of British economy), and failure to acknowledge it leads to paralogism: the uncontrolled transference of propositions to different and inadequate contexts. Hence the importance of knowing what one is doing - which, for Galiani, does not mean embracing an illusory objective stance but adopting a reflexive stance towards one's implicit frame of reference. Thus in his Dialogues sur le commerce des blés, he examines the cases of Sicily, Flanders, England, Naples and Geneva in order to eventually offer his conclusions concerning France. The specificity of Galiani's approach is that it circumvents the question of the theoretical foundations of economics: he develops a method that draws from the historicity of economic theories. In this respect, he goes against a powerful impulse: just as the greatest fear of ethicists is to see philosophical ethics tainted by psychology, economists tend to fight against the dissolution of their discipline in history - its contamination by sociology and political sciences. Galiani's willingness to adopt a theoretically open model appears in the paradoxical form of his Dialogues: They are witty and meandering, bearing no resemblance to the abstract theoretical works of the économistes, yet Galiani’s mouthpiece in the Dialogues constantly exhorts his interlocutors to « reason geometrically ». I will argue that this formal paradox, far from being a mere stylistic peculiarity, must be assessed as an attempt to articulate analytic reasoning and its irreducibly cultural meta-theoretical level. There are many, no doubt, who will be dissatisfied with Galiani’s approach. Yet its relevance today rests precisely in its ability to help us reconsider the equation of scientific validity with orthodoxy, and the conflation of heterodoxy with heresy.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)