ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Oskar Lange and the way IS-LM came to be interpreted as a Walrasian model
Author: Rubin Goulven
The growing importance attributed to the Walrasian theory is a striking feature of the history of contemporary macroeconomics. This is particularly paradoxical as far as Keynesian theory is concerned. Keynes was trained as a Marshallian economist and, except for its general equilibrium perspective, the model of his 1936 General Theory had nothing to do with Walras’ work. Yet, a few years after the publication of Keynes’ book, a number of economists began to present his model, identified with IS-LM, as a particular case of the Walrasian model. This idea appeared in Modigliani in 1944 and in Klein in 1947. Patinkin entry on Keynes for the New Palgrave Dictionary of economics (1991:27) illustrates this tendency. But how did IS-LM come to be interpreted as a Walrasian model? My paper will analyze the first versions of IS-LM, starting with David Champernowne (1936) and Brian Reddaway (1936) and finishing with the contribution of Oskar Lange (1938). The aim will be to show that, contrary to the received view, Hicks’ famous paper on “Mr Keynes and the Classics” did not introduce a Walrasian interpretation of Keynes. Hicks consistently argued that IS-LM was a Marshallian model. This is not only a matter of rhetoric. On can offer a number of analytical reasons why IS-LM could not be Walrasian for Hicks himself. Of course, this contradicts latter statements by Hicks. But when he began to speak of IS-LM as a by product of the Walrasian research program he pursued in the 1930’s, he was actually referring to a model put forward in chapter 22 of Value and Capital that was quite distinct from his 1937 version of IS-LM. Oskar Lange was the one who first introduced the idea that IS-LM should be understood as a simplified version of the Walrasian model of general equilibrium. The paper will examine in detail his argumentation and will answer the following questions. Why did Lange need referring to Walras in order to assess Keynes’ contribution? How could he believe that Keynes’ theory was consistent with the Walrasian model? The aim of this case study is to clarify the reasons why economists in sympathy with the Keynesian project began to consider a synthesis between the General Theory and the general equilibrium theory. As concerns the first question, I will show that a issue of (micro)foundations was at stake. With respect to the second question, I will show that if Lange’s position suffered from fatal weaknesses, he nonetheless offered a consistent rational to treat Keynes’ underemployment equilibrium as a sub-optimal Walrasian equilibrium.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.


.jpg)