ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: How To Do Things With Randomization?
Author: Brisset Nicolas, Favereau Judith


The idea of performativity, developed by Michel Callon (1998), has been used in order to understand the way economists make social entities and phenomena existing. In particular, some recent works (Francesco Guala (2007)) argue that experimental economics is now a major tool to design social world (through the market design) in a way that confirm economic framework. The Nobel Prizes attributed to Vernon Smith, and more recently to Alvin Roth, clearly emphasize the importance of market building in economic theory. In these examples the intervention of experimental economics is clear:: after creating in a laboratory some rules that make people acting as if they were rational, leading the system to efficient result, the economists try to implement them in real institutional world by creating the rules of the markets. During this last decade, experimental economics took a new turn with the significant increase of randomized field experiments (randomization). This new approach is mainly developed by Esther Duflo and Abhijit Banerjee in development economics. Their main goal is to base development policies on evidence. Randomization is often characterized as the “gold standard” methodology in impact evaluation. How does randomization intervene? Does it act like other experimental economics methodologies? Does it perform the economic reality in the same way? The aim of our paper is to investigate these questions. In other words our goal is to shed a light on a possible new link between performativity and experimental economics. The originality of this perspective is to highlight the main issues of the use of randomization in development economics. Our argumentation is constructed in three main sections. In the first section, we will address the following questions: what we “do” with Randomization and how to “do” it? In Callonian vocabulary: what does randomization perform? We will show that Ester Duflo’s experiments make a link between practice and two set of ideas: a set of statistical norms and a set of hierarchical norms. Secondly, we will demonstrate that we can understand the limits of Duflo’s approach in terms of performativity limits. Finally, we will exhibit that these limits force Duflo to fall in a way she originally rejects: paternalism. Therefore, her approach meets a really strong paradox: the wish to base policies decision on evidence is now a political recommendation of paternalism which is not based on any evidence. References : Banerjee, A. and Duflo, E. (2011), Poor Economics. A radical Rethinking of the Way to Fight Global Poverty, Public Affairs, New York. Callon, M. (1998, ed), The Laws of the Markets, Blackwell Publishers, Oxford. Guala, F. (2007).How to Do Things with Experimental Economics. Do Economists Make Markets? . D. MacKenzie, F. Muniesa and L. Siu. Princeton, Princeton University Press: 128-162. Authors : Nicolas Brisset and Judith Favereau.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.