ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The Innovative Entrepreneur in Economic Theory
Author: Knell Mark


William Baumol wrote that the entrepreneur is “one of the most intriguing and one of the most elusive characters in the cast that constitutes the subject of economic analysis.” Although absent in modern economic theory, it has embraced a wide variety of functional roles (or activities) through the history of economic thought. Different economists have identified the entrepreneur as a coordinator, arbitrageur, innovator and the bearer of uncertainty. This paper focuses on the functional role of the entrepreneur as innovator as seen through work of Joseph Schumpeter and Maurice Dobb. Both considered the main function of the entrepreneur to be a pro-active innovator, but Schumpeter came from the neoclassical marginalist tradition and Dobb came from the classical and Marxian tradition. Neither cited each other’s works, other than an odd footnote by Schumpeter that made the point that while Dobb empathized with Marx, his economic analysis was not Marxist. The theoretical context within which these two authors developed their theory of the entreprenure will be important to the story of this paper. Identification the entrepreneur as an active decision maker, relates to the distinction between entrepreneurial personality of individual businessmen, and the function of the entrepreneur as an economic agent. Modern microeconomic theory as reflected in the Arrow-Debreu model neglects the entreprenure because it violates the optimality criterion for decision-making by individual consumers and firms. Aptly, the study of entrepreneur and entrepreneurship is now located in the field of managerial economics where they are considered either as an occupation with the individual as the unit of analysis, or as a market structure with many new and small firms. This paper will mainly consider the entrepreneur as a decision making function or as an agent of change within the economy. The paper is organized around the work of Maurice Dobb and Joseph Schumpeter as individual contributors to the history or economic thought, and as representatives of the classical theory of value and distribution and the early marginalist theory of value and distribution, respectively. Since there is little evidence that Dobb knew Schumpeter’s work (in German at the time) when he wrote about the entrepreneur, the essay considers the classical approach and Dobb first and the early marginalist approach and Schumpeter secondly. In classical political economy, English writers preferred to use the word undertaker instead of entrepreneur. in 1924 Dobb chose consciously to use the word entrepreneur to represent the decision making function, and the word undertaker to represent the person fulfilling the function. Schumpeter used the German word Unternehmergeist in the 1911 first edition in German to reflect the different function he gave the Walrasian entrepreneur, but then returned to the French word in the English edition. A final section considers the dichotomy between the entrepreneur in theory and the entrepreneur in practice through the vision of these economists. It asks whether the entrepreneur should be an important agent in economic theory, remain solely in the domain of business studies, or bridge the two disciplines.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.