ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Malthus's war on poverty as moral reform
Author: CREMASCHI Sergio


My main claim is that Malthus viewed his own population theory and political economy as parts of the moral and political science. I discuss four points: 1. The function of the test of Utility as a way of discovering the will of God, and accordingly the laws of nature, which he has imposed on this Creation, in their positive contents. The test of utility is a test for detecting whether a maxim is a law of nature, not a standard for establishing what is right and wrong or, in other words, that it is a clue for detecting the will of God (who has established in his full right – being omnipotent – but not arbitrarily – being benevolent and omniscient – what is right and what is wrong). 2. Malthus’s virtue ethics: his normative ethics focuses on two main ‘natural’ virtues, that is, benevolence and chastity. In a social, but pre-political, state such as that of men living without government and law, there would be at least a few, albeit rather loosely defined duties, those of helping one’s neighbour and of forming a stable attachment to a person of the other sex. To men living in such a state, these would be taught to be laws of nature by experience, since they might easily notice the nefarious consequences of acting according to opposite lines. There is a second group of virtues: artificial virtues, which begin to exist as soon as the transition to the political state is accomplished; to such kind of virtues love for equality and love for liberty belong. Special place is granted to a fifth virtue, Prudence, which governs both individual quest for happiness and collective quest for the public good. This special virtue also provides an invisible link between the private and the public domains, in so far as it contributes in combining self-love with general happiness through the unintended results mechanism, by which “the most ignorant are led to promote the general happiness”, since all “the greatest improvements” are effected thanks to an effort by each individual in pursuing his own “interest and happiness”. 3. Malthus’s sexual morality. He points at chastity as an overarching virtue, describes the joys of “virtuous love” (Malthus 1803, II: 90) as the prize for such virtue, defines marital fidelity as a specification of chastity in the given social conditions, and the duty of marrying only at a time when one is ready to carry the burden of six children as a moral duty imposed by prudence and enjoined by a “law of nature” which we can detect through observation of the order of creation. Besides he points at disadvantages of early marriage mainly for women, and finally rejects birth control within marriage with such reasons as its supposed effect of encouraging ‘indolence’. 4.Malthus’s views on justice and beneficence vis-à-vis poverty. Through subsequent approximations and under pressure of critics, Malthus yields finally a kind of Institutionalist approach to policies concerning poverty, making room for generalized basic education, free markets for labour and (from a certain date on) for corn, and allowing for a subsidiary role for private beneficence. The goal to be aimed at by such a mix of policies is bringing about “circumstances which tend to elevate the character of the lower classes of society, which make them approach the nearest to beings who ‘look before and after’, and who consequently cannot acquiesce patiently in the thought of depriving themselves and their children of the means of being respectable, virtuous and happy”.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.