ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Untangling Adam Smith’s historical-analytical approach
Author: Brown Vivienne


Session: Historical Political Economy Author: Vivienne Brown As is widely recognised, Adam Smith’s approach to social and economic enquiry was rooted in an understanding of the significance of historical change. His methodological approach is sometimes characterised as ‘conjectural history’ – an explanation of events based on conjectures about human responses to changing conditions. This seems to imply the combination of an analytic approach to social explanation with an appreciation of historical change, a combination that might seem particularly attractive for historical political economy. Smith’s conception of the stages of society, for example, from the rude state, through pasturage, agriculture and commercial society, is indicative of this. Yet this raises a number of questions about the relation between Smith’s economic theory and his account of historical change. Does this relation amount to the articulation of two independent spheres, or is this relation governed by a higher-order level of theorising? The Wealth of Nations consists of an intermingling of theory and historical observations, but many commentators have been puzzled by (or tend to ignore) the inclusion of historical arguments about economic progress (the ‘progress of opulence’) in the third, and central, book of the work. This third book presents a theoretical view of economic history that is integral to the economic analysis of the work in that the account of ‘the system of natural liberty’ is dependent on a particular view of European economic history as the progressive and hence, ‘natural’, expansion of economic activity. Interruptions to what is presented as a natural economic dynamics of development are therefore presented as an ‘unnatural’ historical order of development. Does this suggest that the relation between Smith’s economic theory and his history of economic development is governed by a meta-theory of some sort. This paper will consider this question and how such a meta-theory of historical economics might be understood (eg in terms of Smith’s anthropology, the role of ‘providence’?).

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.